I can't decide.

[Mike Holbrook]

I made my comments about the #8, knowing the OP specifically asked about it. I was specifically thinking that he might want a larger perspective regarding the #8 related to general use and the planes he has. He actually mentioned the LV BU jointer and jack plane first.

Certainly the new Custom Veritas planes bare much more in common with their predecessor BU family members than Stanley type planes. The OP apparently has a Veritas BU plane now and would have some familiarity with the adjustment system and features. He apparently has access to other LV planes too, so he can try them before buying.

Patrick it is good to know I got at least one out of three of my comments to the OP half "right" in your opinion ;-) Maybe it would be more appropriate to address your comments to the OP instead of correcting and editing other posters.