I'm more of the chaotic organizer type. It all looks like a mess. But the piles are organized according to my own logic, so I almost never lose anything. And I'm really strict about adhering to my system. But God help someone else trying to find something in my system.
As an example, I have a drawer full of glue and rulers. Why? Because masking tape is a kind of adhesive, like glue. And a tape measure is a kind of tape. And rulers are like tape measures. Makes sense to me!