Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 23

Thread: Hand planes

  1. #1

    Hand planes

    Turning forever, but trying to get into flat work, which I gave up because I was a better turner. Anyway, I have a number of planes, and the soles on them are all slightly concave. Is this a design element? I always thought they were supposed to be dead flat. These include a Stanley jointer plane, some Lie Neilson planes, and even a Bridge City 12 inch plane.

    I do have one cheap maroon Stanley one that was really bad, and got it dead flat on a granite stone with 80 and 220 grit abrasives.

    robo hippy

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Longview WA
    Posts
    27,347
    Blog Entries
    1
    I have a number of planes, and the soles on them are all slightly concave. Is this a design element?
    To the best of my knowledge it is not a design element. It may have been caused by someone trying to lap the sole without knowing what they were doing.

    There is likely to be as much disagreement on this point than there is on sharpening.

    The biggest problem with a concave sole, imo, is the blade will not engage until it is advanced enough to touch the wood. Then it will dig in and take a much thicker shaving than intended. Otherwise, with downward pressure the blade will engage but disengage if the pressure is decreased. It is enough to make a person want to give up trying to plane a piece of wood.

    What are you using to check the sole and how concave is "slightly concave?"

    My preference is for my smoothers to be able to take a very fine shaving. My jointers are fine if they can take a moderately fine shaving, about 0.003" or so, as long as they do not have the problems mentioned above.

    jtk
    "A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty."
    - Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965)

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Apr 2021
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    652
    Might be a silly question, but have you verified your straight edge is straight? I wouldn’t think all of those planes would be out of flat given the manufacturers. Did you buy them new?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Peoria, IL
    Posts
    4,444
    Japanese hand planes use 2 different patterns on the working surface, one for truing and one for smoothing. They definitely not dead flat. Western planes do work better with flat and what you have was not intentionally a design element. If the Lie Neilsen is way off, call them and they will make it right.

  5. #5
    I think the concave surface is usually from planing dirty wood . You know ,boards that were first into the truck bed sand pile. Old timers I
    worked with had no patience for guys who would plane grit.
    Worker: It’s My plane.
    Boss: But you are re-sharpening on my time !
    Some say that needless wear causes tear-out from from ‘rock peeling’ ( worn down steel front that won’t hold down wood surface down ,because of careless wear.
    Last edited by Mel Fulks; 08-19-2022 at 5:00 PM. Reason: MORE !

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Longview WA
    Posts
    27,347
    Blog Entries
    1
    Old timers I worked with had no patience for guys who would plane grit.
    Any piece of wood that looks dirty, even just cobwebs gets brushed off before a plane touches it. Sometimes it is a wire brush, sometimes not.

    Even after sanding the wood should be cleaned before planing.

    jtk
    "A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty."
    - Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965)

  7. #7
    Just wondering if you meant the opposite and the planes are infact convex?

    Are you checking with a clean surface plate with feelers or doing similar stuff like hinging.......

    Or did you check the pattern left from the abrasive with the plane turned upside down, and you see shined up toe and heel before anything else?

    The latter should be the case if they are actually flat, as abrasion favours the edges,
    and if you've done so, then chances are the plane is now slightly convex, by like a sheet of paper, which is around where one wants to be.

    Going further will throw it out of whack if using a larger surface area of abrasive, than the plane is long,
    and the only way to put that right is spot working with various methods,
    I lay an abrasive strip not quite as wide, or as long as the particular plane being worked, and stack another identical size strip on top of that,
    some prefer to use a wooden block and test on the plate afterwards with some blue or permanent marker.

    If you still think otherwise, note that no one will show the results honestly which involves a surface plate and feelers.

    What I'm talking about ain't for rocket science tolerances, but depending on how eager one might be,
    one could unknowingly remove a good few pages and the cover! worth of material from toe and heel by believing a complete scratch pattern
    means flat.
    Just saying check the plane on something clean, and take note of toe and heel, could you slide anything under?
    Keep an eye on that, as it's a lot of work to put right again.
    Rob Cosman demonstrating flatness Luban vs WoodRiver.jpg
    Tom
    Last edited by Tom Trees; 08-19-2022 at 7:32 PM.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    twomiles from the "peak of Ohio
    Posts
    12,120
    First off..throw the dang feeler gauges back into the drawer with rest of the Car Ignition tools, let me know when you are done with that


    Dis-regard all you hear from the Flat Sole Group.....class them over with the Flat Earth Group.


    You will need both of your index fingers....one for each end of the plane. one on the heel, the other on the toe...First, have them diagonally to each other..and press down...any wiggle? Next have them right in the center line, repeat the pressing down...any wiggles? If not, just shine the sole up, sharpen the iron, and put them back to work.

    Has worked for me for about 50 years, so far.....

    Wood bodied planes MIGHT warp...highly unlikely that cast iron will.....unless they had been in a fire at some time ( Fire Sale! )....
    A Planer? I'm the Planer, and this is what I use

  9. #9
    Okay, several things here. First attempts to use the planes left me with a big arc, convex along the length of the board. Figured out that was mostly because of too much pressure on the nose when going off the end of the board. I also had a 10 or more degree angle to the top of the board. So, all pressure on the heel of the plane when going off the end of the board, and learned how to get the blade square to the plane body. Solved those problems, well mostly, still need more practice... I have been trying to take down a couple of boards, doug fir, and alder, to nothing but shavings, using low angle jack plane, jointer plane, 45 degree plane. Some times all goes well with a single full width shaving, and some times I get shavings that are full width to start, then switch to one side or the other of the board before I get to the end. Some of this was from the blade being too loose. Some of it seems to be from the sole of the plane not being flat across. This was worse with the Bridge City plane which I sent back. To check them for flatness, I place a straight edge nose to tail, and hold it up to my ceiling shop lights to see how much light shows underneath. Almost all of them have the heel and nose higher than the center of the plane. I lay a straight edge across the sole, and get similar results, with the outsides being higher than the center, which to me would explain the side to side shavings. I did use the 24 inch straight edges from Bridge City, and got identical sightings from all 4 sides of 2 rulers. I used a couple of their squares and straight edges to sight across the sole of the plane. The alder board started out 6/4 by about 6 inches tall. Now it is 3 1/8 on the starting end, and 2 3/8 on the finish end of the cut. Best guess is that since the tails on the planes are all a bit proud of the flat line, that is raising the heel of the plane as it goes off the board. The surface is not dead flat, but close enough so that if I was jointing some 4/4 boards, I could squeeze them into perfect allignment.

    Getting the irons sharp has been the simple part. Diamond lapping plates and jigs. No one makes any kind of 'what am I doing wrong' videos on You Tube about what you will have to go through to learn to use the planes.... Have any of you watched Face Edge Woodworking from over in the UK? He sharpens on an old Norton India stone, strops with auto polish and that is his finished cutting edge. No jigs, all by hand and eye. I tried it on a 220 grit diamond plate and stropped. It actually cuts very nicely, though not as polished as if I used the 15000 grit diamond paste from DMT. Also watched Stumpy Nubs, Johnathon Katz Moses, Rob Cosman, and Matt Estlea from the UK.

    The adventure continues....

    robo hippy

  10. #10
    Join Date
    May 2021
    Location
    Spartanburg South Carolina
    Posts
    386
    I think most of your taper is due to technique. It took a lot of work to make me put full pressure on the toe at the start and zero at the end of the pass a habit. I also still need to do some stopped passes to adjust on the fly in some cases. Most of my old users show more wear on the leading edge of the toe than anywhere else but it doesn't seem to cause much trouble. If the flatness is bothering you go ahead and flatten it. The scratch pattern will quickly reveal how off it is. Leave the iron and frog in but retract the iron so the plane will be at its normal "flex". I usually only do this if I am doing a full rehab. I like using a granite countertop back splash to do this because it gives me a longer ramp to work with.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Longview WA
    Posts
    27,347
    Blog Entries
    1
    The scratch pattern will quickly reveal how off it is. Leave the iron and frog in but retract the iron so the plane will be at its normal "flex". I usually only do this if I am doing a full rehab.
    As one who used to advocate the lapping of soles, my position now is to only lap them if it can be proven there is a need to lap a sole.

    Many have likely done as much to distort the sole of a plane as have actually corrected a distorted sole.

    If a plane's sole has a slight convexity it is very easy to increase the convexity with misdirected effort to flatten.

    The cast iron of a plane's sole is quickly removed by abrasives. The particles of iron get caught up between the particles of abrasive and influence the work.

    It is important to remove the powdered iron regularly, a large magnet wrapped in paper works for me.

    It is important to check the work often and be able to remove metal from small isolated areas.

    One of my old users was lapped by previous owners to the extent the sole was too thin to remain stable. Variations in the shop temperature would cause tensions between the frog and the base, causing the sole to change. All the other parts on the plane are good, but the sole can be a problem when the weather changes.

    jtk
    "A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty."
    - Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965)

  12. #12
    Join Date
    May 2021
    Location
    Spartanburg South Carolina
    Posts
    386
    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Koepke View Post
    As one who used to advocate the lapping of soles, my position now is to only lap them if it can be proven there is a need to lap a sole.

    Many have likely done as much to distort the sole of a plane as have actually corrected a distorted sole.

    If a plane's sole has a slight convexity it is very easy to increase the convexity with misdirected effort to flatten.

    The cast iron of a plane's sole is quickly removed by abrasives. The particles of iron get caught up between the particles of abrasive and influence the work.

    It is important to remove the powdered iron regularly, a large magnet wrapped in paper works for me.

    It is important to check the work often and be able to remove metal from small isolated areas.

    One of my old users was lapped by previous owners to the extent the sole was too thin to remain stable. Variations in the shop temperature would cause tensions between the frog and the base, causing the sole to change. All the other parts on the plane are good, but the sole can be a problem when the weather changes.

    jtk
    Yeah, if it ain't broke don't fix it. I have never had an issue with a plane (I think I have almost sixty now) that I would feel the need to alter the sole to cure. It was more about making it shiny as a secret Santa project but while I was at it I might as well make it dead flat. Not sure why but as the paper filled with iron filings I would use the shop vac often to remove them, never thought about the buildup changing the pattern. And good God, if someone laps a plane to the point of making it too thin they are using power to do it or they feel the need to do it every time they hone the iron IMO. I can remember a Wood Talk episode where one of them attempted to "fix" a LN plane. The LN rep took one look at it and said "what did you do to this plane!"

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Koepke View Post
    As one who used to advocate the lapping of soles, my position now is to only lap them if it can be proven there is a need to lap a sole.

    Many have likely done as much to distort the sole of a plane as have actually corrected a distorted sole.

    If a plane's sole has a slight convexity it is very easy to increase the convexity with misdirected effort to flatten.

    The cast iron of a plane's sole is quickly removed by abrasives. The particles of iron get caught up between the particles of abrasive and influence the work.

    It is important to remove the powdered iron regularly, a large magnet wrapped in paper works for me.

    It is important to check the work often and be able to remove metal from small isolated areas.

    One of my old users was lapped by previous owners to the extent the sole was too thin to remain stable. Variations in the shop temperature would cause tensions between the frog and the base, causing the sole to change. All the other parts on the plane are good, but the sole can be a problem when the weather changes.

    jtk
    The same thing will happen with a clean lap, it's not the loose grit that causes the issue,
    Not saying that it doesn't amplify what's happening, but same deal would happen if the lap were upside down.

    Just like a file will do the same, no matter how careful one is
    SAM_5789.jpg
    https://postimg.cc/dhGgXVXq


    @Reed I'm reading plenty of issues with technique, may I suggest the late great David Charlesworth,
    particularly some snippets regarding "stopped shavings"
    He made some videos, one of which was and still is the best planing video I've ever seen to date.
    It was the old one at a gathering, not a newer one which I've not seen.

    He's one of the only ones who don't have bad habits, and was both extremely precise and honest,
    It's been at least a decade, and no one has come close to making a video that's even half as good.


    Tom

  14. #14
    Unless I missed the information, I think the most important question is: did you purchase all of these planes new? Or from a third party who many have screwed them all up trying to “tune” them with bad info? The defect you are describing is so utterly bizarre that I cannot imagine the same defect coming from different makers and all going to the same customer. Which is why I ask if this collection of planes previously belonged to the same person.

    I only have two metal soled bench planes, a newer Stanley Sweetheart and a Veritas LAJ. I just checked and they are both dead flat. The vast majority of my bench planes have wood soles and they are all dead flat because I periodically flatten them to make sure they are dead flat. When they get out of flat they do not cut well.

    The planing problems described do not sound like concave sole problems. They sound like “practice has yet to make perfect.” While I have no experience with how out of flat metal soles affect planing, I have plenty of experience with wooden soles that are not flat and they don’t behave the way that was described. And although the corners can get worn down (not really all that important), the biggest issue is hollowing out near the mouth, meaning concave along the x and z axis (sorta like the OP described). Instead, they just become very finicky cutters. They will cut fine until the board gets pretty flat and then suddenly stop cutting. They will stutter cut. The cut will go from not cutting to cutting way too deep. Stuff like that. Luckily on a wooden sole, this is fixed in just a few minutes.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Stone Mountain, GA
    Posts
    751
    A concave sole is no good for a bench plane. Even a tiny amount of concavity that is within a high-end manufacturer's tolerance can cause problems. L-N's flatness tolerance is +-0.0015" which is very good, but you can notice even 0.0015" concavity when you try to create or maintain a straight surface. It's always wanting to take too much off at the ends. I think it also leads to issues with chatter, or inconsistent cutter engagement. On the other hand, a slightly convex sole isn't a big deal. I'd rather have a plane that's 0.005" convex than 0.0015" concave.

    It's true that beginners will tend to plane too much on the ends until they develop better technique, but the equipment can be limiting as well. How does the Stanley that you flattened perform now? Can you tell a difference?

    The good news is that its generally easier and less work to flatten a concave sole than a convex one. But when lapping you cannot use heavy pressure or you will flex the concavity right out. Use minimal pressure and keep the abrasive fresh and sharp.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •