As promised in this thread, I tried out my new sharpening system and wanted to share my thoughts.
Background: I started with sandpaper on glass about 15 years ago and it's served my well. About 12 years ago I mounted 2 1/2 x 11 glass blocks on MDF and used them as a base for 3M abrasive film. I would cycle through the 5 available grits from 40 micron to .3 micron and wind up with a pretty nice edge. The only complaints I had were the time it took and the durability of the film.
I watched the Rob Cosman video where he goes directly from a 1000 grit Trend Diamond plate to a 16K Grit Shapton and achieves a stupid sharp edge in under a minute. I thought, sure...how can that work? I was down in Indy earlier this year and stopped at Woodcraft to do a little window shopping and the resident sharpening guru was promoting the same system. He gave a demo where he dulled up a plane iron in a big way then put a new edge on it. Darned if it didn't work.
Last week I was at a point where I had to order some more film. Santa determined it was time to take the plunge so he ordered me the same setup Rob Cosman and Woodcraft were promoting, a 300/1000 Trend Diamond Plate and a 16K Shapton.
First off, they work great. Just as promised and just as demonstrated. It takes up far less space too. It is a whole different experience.
The Trend Diamond Plate was very flat right out of the box. I used the 300 grit side to dress a steel plate I have to free up any stray diamond particles that might gough the Shapton Stone during flattening (Cosman recommended). It didn't seem to be an issue. The 1000 grit side establishes a secondary bevel very quickly and with very little pressure
The 16K Shapton cuts amazingly fast for being as fine as it is. By comparison, the .3 micron 3M film doesn't cut at all, it just polishes. I was able to establish a mirror finish tertiary bevel with just a few strokes. I freehanded my chisels and all but one plane iron. My LN jig worked well for that one.
The edge quality I achieved is better than ever. Off the 16K Shapton it was even better than off the strops I've made. The process is very speedy too. Once the dust settles from Christmas I'll likely add an intermediate grit Shapton (4K or 6K) for day to day use and save the Trend Diamond Plate for heavier work and for flattening the Shaptons occasionally.
The whole kit was kind of spendy, but if I look at what I've spent on abrasive film and other supplies over the years I think I'll be money ahead eventually. I sure will save a bunch of time.