Power screwdriver

[Dave Lehnert]

Looking for a power screwdriver something like in the link.
https://www.amazon.com/SD561801-SKIL...R6RJCXCV0D32CP

I fully understand they are not a power drill and what they are good for. Looking for something to replace a screwdriver when I have many small screws to twist.
Hard to tell by the reviews because some expect them to do the job of an impact driver.

My old Craftsman like this one was great but lost it. It had a clutch, something I don't see in today offerings.
https://www.amazon.com/Craftsman-vol.../dp/B001O4GR2G
The price in the link is crazy. It was $30 item.

[David Buchhauser]

What about this one? I like Milwaukee.
David
https://www.amazon.com/Milwaukee-Lit...s%2C210&sr=1-3

[Bruce Lowekamp]

I have the Dewalt 8v gyroscopic screwdriver. Love it. It sits upstairs mostly for around the house work, though I'll occasionally grab it for other projects if I need the stick form factor. I also have a 12v pistol grip screwdriver in the shop that I use when I want a bit more finesse than my impact driver (though I've been reading modern impact drivers can be more subtle and might need to upgrade)

Bruce

[John Lanciani]

What about this one? I like Milwaukee.
David
https://www.amazon.com/Milwaukee-Lit...s%2C210&sr=1-3

Or if you prefer blue over red the Bosch PS-21 or PS-22 are my favorites.

[Alex Zeller]

I use a Milwaukee one at work. I have both the older version and the new version one. The new version has an electronic clutch vs the old one is mechanical. On the new one when you reach the clutch setting it clicks and then shuts off saving the battery. It's probably got the same power as your Craftsman one.
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Milwauke...E&gclsrc=aw.ds

[Dan Rude]

I use my Milwaukee m12 for light duty screwing, the speed is a little slow for drilling. I have an older Craftsman impact screwdriver it is either straight or pivots to a pistol. Have not used it in years though. the new one is Craftsman 8V MAX Cordless Impact Screwdriver https://www.sears.com/craftsman-8v-m...000P?rrec=true. I sold my older B&D versa pack, which worked good. I like the extra power in the Milwaukee, and able to change batteries. Ryobi, makes 2 types one with there 4V battery system and one without. https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-4-...P54L/205545276 or https://www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-4-...P44L/205975772. Dan

[Robert Hayward]

Here is one I like:
https://www.amazon.com/Metabo-HPT-DB.../dp/B07L78Y72J

[Bruce Page]

Having no clutch would be a show stopper for me, especially when driving small screws.

[Ed Edwards]

I'll ditto Bob H's recommendation for the Metabo

Ed

[Frederick Skelly]

Guys, I've obviously missed something that matters when driving screws. What is the benefit of using an electric screwdriver instead of my Milwaukee drill? I generally drive small screws by hand, for the control. I've never considered a dedicated electric srewdriver.

Thank you.
Fred

[Jack Frederick]

A friend bought this Dewalt gyroscopic unit. Tip your wrist left and it will unscrew, rt to tighten. Tip slowly and it goes slowly. I tried it a few times and perhaps it will become all the rage, but I was working off a ladder and had the thing going as I was trying to address the screw. On a bench it might be ok but first glance for me didn't do it. I've had the 6.2 V Dewalt screwdriver for 20 yrs, but have replaced then with the M12 Milwaukee drill/driver.https
://www.amazon.com/DEWALT-DCF682N1-Gyroscopic-Inline-Screwdriver/dp/B011WRUODC/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&gclid=CjwKCAjwlZf3BRABEiwA8Q0q q04XDlR2HqhyoAgP2FKDtzzfb-cVZlUURB0iX5K1W6SHBqCE_dXkABoCgpIQAvD_BwE&hvadid=1 77827143595&hvdev=c&hvlocphy=9032596&hvnetw=g&hvqm t=b&hvrand=13134306413672783917&hvtargid=kwd-2248950000&hydadcr=1669_9901583&keywords=dewalt+co rdless+screwdriver+kit&qid=1592147045&sr=8-2&tag=googhydr-20

[Jim Tobias]

Dave,
I have that exact one....someone gave it to me as a gift. It is excellent for removing screws and putting screws back in place(things I use a Screwdriver for). It would not be of use for drilling screws into wood, etc. If I am understanding your post, you are looking for something that makes that task easier. IT does. It is small (not too long) and is easy to control . Charges with a plug much like a cell phone...USB into a plug.
I keep mine in a drawer in the house and use it all the time rather than go into the shop and pull out a Milwaukee, Dewalt, etc.......Overkill.
IMHO.

Jim

[Jim Becker]

Guys, I've obviously missed something that matters when driving screws. What is the benefit of using an electric screwdriver instead of my Milwaukee drill? I generally drive small screws by hand, for the control. I've never considered a dedicated electric srewdriver.

I think that the theory is that they can be more comfortable to hold when driving screws when you don't need the extra power that a drill/driver brings at the trade-off of more weight and size. My opinion is that they are "probably" more useful for typical homeowner needs as compared to woodworking needs, but that's certainly going to be subjective. I use a Festool CSX for most fastener driving in my shop because the lower weight is a lot easier on my wrists and even bring it into the house when I have driving tasks that I want a motor behind. But I'd consider having a driver-stick type device in the house tool drawer, especially now with better battery technology. The old ones didn't last when I previously (many years ago) owned a couple.

[Jim Tobias]

Just to clarify....this is not a plug in electric screwdriver. You plug it in to charge the lithium battery using a Mini USB type plug. It is fully portable and hold a charge for at least a couple of months. I've not tested it per se but I have only charged it once in the 6 months I've had it.

Jim

20200614_134348.jpg20200614_134353.jpg

[Bruce Lowekamp]

My opinion is that they are "probably" more useful for typical homeowner needs as compared to woodworking needs, but that's certainly going to be subjective.

Yeah, this is why I keep the 8v gyroscopic screwdriver upstairs. It’s perfect for doing things like disassembling the stick vac when it gets clogged, has 12 screws holding the bottom on. Originally I got it when I had stitches from a saw accident (another story, still have all fingers) and couldn’t operate triggers.

The 12v screwdriver is strong enough to use in the shop when I’m pre-drilling holes. If I’m just slamming screws into boards for rough carpentry, jigs etc, that’s what the impact driver is for.

Bruce