As the title suggests, im trying to determine which slick to keep and which to sell. Both need handles made, shouldnt be an issue. Both seem to be in about the same condition. Maybe the Witherby eeks out a win there. The PSW has a 1/16" chip in the middle of the blade that would need to be honed out. Other than that, they are both enormous slicks. 3-15/16" wide and 16-17" long. The PSW has an additional 1"+/- of length on the Witherby. From what i can read from simple searches, they are widely considered to be good chisel makers. I know comparisons are subjective, but anyone familiar enough with both makers to offer advice on which to keep? Im leaning towards the TH Witherby, but if they are about the same working quality, but one is worth more than the other, then i am selling the more valuable/collectible slick. I purchased them awhile ago with the intention of starting a small 10x12 timber frame shed. The proceeds from the sale will go towards the purchase of a 1.5" Barr.