Last edited by Christian Hawkshaw; 10-09-2019 at 7:20 PM.
Chris
I do some of each. For my more heirloom type pieces I do wooden. For drawers that get used a lot, kitchens, bathrooms, shop cabinets, etc, I use metal. Some soft close some cheapies.
Note even good quality metal slides in a high use area like a kitchen or tool box will wear out eventually. My kitchen was built in 1970 and they are all going, but that is pretty good life.
The wooden ones, depending on how you do them, can be susceptible to seasonal movement.
I have had good luck with NK style wooden slides. They allow a larger bearing surface and run smooth and less seasonal sticking.
I don't think I've seen two of the biggest reasons for metal slides mentioned in the responses yet.
1. A ball bearing slide will reduce the load on the drawer substantially and increase its life, which is especially important for drawers that may be heavy with contents.
2. For a furniture maker, a drawer that is wider than it is deep presents a considerably greater binding challenge. This is why traditional furniture makers broke up pieces into multiple drawers on a row, at least as much as they could. Anyone who has ever struggled with a wide dresser drawer that binds knows what I mean. Ball bearing slides changed the game and allows us to design without these restrictions and end up with a silky smooth running drawer, even when loaded.
Don't want to see metal? Blum Tandems and Hettich Quadros are your ticket.