I hope, when you were in Old Salem, that you had time to visit the Museum of Early Southern Decorative Arts. https://mesda.org/
If not, plan to go back, and have several hours to spend there. They have complete original rooms from different periods.
The shop in Williamsburg is better.
edited to add: When approaching Jamestown on the ferry, look over to where you think the original colony started. Someone on board might be able to tell you. I was riding across there with an Architectural Historian, soon after they had found the original location. He told me that they hadn't ever looked there before, and it had been a long time. I told him that they must not have ever looked from the water. The colonists came by boat. That was the first place I would have looked.