Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 24

Thread: Drill Press Questions

  1. #1

    Drill Press Questions

    Okay, so I am thinking of replacing my little HF 8" - 5 speed bench top drill press. It has actually served me well. I am not a huge HF fan, but I have had good luck with some of my HF tools. The quill had a ton of slop as delivered, but that was easily adjusted out. Since the majority of my work (mostly luthier work) is light duty this drill press really served well most of the time within its several limitations.

    So what has it NOT done that I'd like:
    1. The table does not have a geared height adjustment. This is a fairly major hassle IMO.
    2. It does not have a long enough stroke length. Two inches is pretty short.
    3. You can't drill far enough from the edge of the material. The center of the spindle is only 4" from the column. This is a limitation more often than I'd like.
    4. It is a little under powered.
    5. A little lower low speed would be nice as would easier speed changes.
    6. The whole thing isn't real high quality. It actually has worked well for a few years so i am not completely bummed, but better quality would be a nice.


    To be fair... Most of these drawbacks apply to most of the models in this size regardless of brand.

    This one has served well enough that I might actually consider another HF model in a bit larger model with some of the lacking features added, but I am tempted to spring for something in a nicer brand.

    Given my needs and available space I will most likely stick with a bench top model. If a nice older Delta or something similar were to show up on craigslist I would not rule out used. I don't need to spindle sand on the drill press (I have a dedicated Triton spindle sander) and generally don't need bells and whistles, just a solid drilling machine.

    Thoughts? Suggestions?

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    E TN, near Knoxville
    Posts
    12,298
    Hats off to luthiers!

    I don't have a specific recommendation. I have two Delta drill presses, bought the first one, a bench-top, about 20 years ago and more recently added a floor model. I don't know if they are all like this but between these two the floor model has significantly longer quill travel. I have the floor model in my wood shop and keep the bench-top for metal now.

    I'm quite happy with the operation of both. The controls and precision on both are fine. I don't remember the speed range but I they do have much slower speeds than I usually use.

    I also would want more than 4" from the support column. If you do get a larger drill press, you might consider keeping the small one and modifying it for a bit more clearance.

    JKJ

    Quote Originally Posted by Pete Staehling View Post
    Okay, so I am thinking of replacing my little HF 8" - 5 speed bench top drill press. It has actually served me well. I am not a huge HF fan, but I have had good luck with some of my HF tools. The quill had a ton of slop as delivered, but that was easily adjusted out. Since the majority of my work (mostly luthier work) is light duty this drill press really served well most of the time within its several limitations.

    So what has it NOT done that I'd like:
    1. The table does not have a geared height adjustment. This is a fairly major hassle IMO.
    2. It does not have a long enough stroke length. Two inches is pretty short.
    3. You can't drill far enough from the edge of the material. The center of the spindle is only 4" from the column. This is a limitation more often than I'd like.
    4. It is a little under powered.
    5. A little lower low speed would be nice as would easier speed changes.
    6. The whole thing isn't real high quality. It actually has worked well for a few years so i am not completely bummed, but better quality would be a nice.


    To be fair... Most of these drawbacks apply to most of the models in this size regardless of brand.

    This one has served well enough that I might actually consider another HF model in a bit larger model with some of the lacking features added, but I am tempted to spring for something in a nicer brand.

    Given my needs and available space I will most likely stick with a bench top model. If a nice older Delta or something similar were to show up on craigslist I would not rule out used. I don't need to spindle sand on the drill press (I have a dedicated Triton spindle sander) and generally don't need bells and whistles, just a solid drilling machine.

    Thoughts? Suggestions?

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    SoCal
    Posts
    22,494
    Blog Entries
    1
    The near endless search for a decent drill press under $2500 . . . We need your budget in order to make an intelligent suggestion.

    The Delta 18-900 still gets my vote despite concerns about parts and a questionable trunnion clamping design. For things cheaper than that, the Grizzly 7943 and 7944 give you a 7" depth, 140 RPM at the low end (a low speed is a must IMHO) and 3050 RPM at the high end, all in a no frills but, proven design, basic drill press.

    There's a plethora of DP's between $500 and $1500, all have one deficiency or the other depending on what is important to you. In my years searching for something that is an upgrade from my old Delta 17-950 I have found nothing better under $1000 and many no-better for more than that.
    "A hen is only an egg's way of making another egg".


    – Samuel Butler

  4. #4
    I've built several guitars and no doubt the drill press is a great tool to have. Woodcraft had a great sale on Jet DX17 (floor model) at a time I wanted to move up from an antique Asian benchtop I had. What a difference! The additional height has come in handy when drilling wire channels through the body.


    Fine Woodworking did a woodworking drill press tool test a couple of years ago. One of the criteria they mentioned was a must was a large table. IIRC, a Powermatic electronic speed control model took top honors but it's pricey. The Jet I bought was around $500 at the time. It's my go-to for luthier work, including using it as a fret press. It doesn't take up much floor space and the area underneath it often is used for tool storage.
    “Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness..." - Mark Twain

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by Pete Staehling View Post
    Okay, so I am thinking of replacing my little HF 8" - 5 speed bench top drill press. It has actually served me well. I am not a huge HF fan, but I have had good luck with some of my HF tools. The quill had a ton of slop as delivered, but that was easily adjusted out. Since the majority of my work (mostly luthier work) is light duty this drill press really served well most of the time within its several limitations.

    So what has it NOT done that I'd like:
    1. The table does not have a geared height adjustment. This is a fairly major hassle IMO.
    2. It does not have a long enough stroke length. Two inches is pretty short.
    3. You can't drill far enough from the edge of the material. The center of the spindle is only 4" from the column. This is a limitation more often than I'd like.
    4. It is a little under powered.
    5. A little lower low speed would be nice as would easier speed changes.
    6. The whole thing isn't real high quality. It actually has worked well for a few years so i am not completely bummed, but better quality would be a nice.


    To be fair... Most of these drawbacks apply to most of the models in this size regardless of brand.

    This one has served well enough that I might actually consider another HF model in a bit larger model with some of the lacking features added, but I am tempted to spring for something in a nicer brand.

    Given my needs and available space I will most likely stick with a bench top model. If a nice older Delta or something similar were to show up on craigslist I would not rule out used. I don't need to spindle sand on the drill press (I have a dedicated Triton spindle sander) and generally don't need bells and whistles, just a solid drilling machine.

    Thoughts? Suggestions?
    I would recommend getting a decent quality older unit, such as the vintage Deltas, Powermatics, Clausings, Buffalos, etc. They are much better put-together than the inexpensive import units everybody else sells, although one of those may be enough for you.

  6. #6
    Thanks. I will mull all that over a while before deciding.

  7. #7
    On a side note... I checked out the Craftsman 12" bench top at Sears and was surprised to find that it seemed pretty cheaply made. Maybe it was just that the floor model was in bad shape, but there seemed to be tons of play in places that didn't look like they could be adjusted out. Has anyone checked one out lately and care to comment?

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by Phillip Gregory View Post
    I would recommend getting a decent quality older unit, such as the vintage Deltas, Powermatics, Clausings, Buffalos, etc. They are much better put-together than the inexpensive import units everybody else sells, although one of those may be enough for you.
    That's the best advice I've seen. I might add the qualifier to the word "vintage" and make it "USA-made" Some of those brands have been selling the low value imports long enough to almost qualify as "vintage".

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Sep 2016
    Location
    Central Missouri, U.S.
    Posts
    1,263
    Pete, I don't know if you'd call it "lately", but I bought a 10" Craftsman benchtop unit about 3 years ago. I'd say it's just OK. Tolerable runout for my uses, but not what I'd call precision. Actually, I can't think of any modern day Craftsman machine that I'd call precision.

    That said, I wouldn't judge any machine from a floor model. No telling who put it together or what kind of abuse it might have seen.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    SoCal
    Posts
    22,494
    Blog Entries
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by Pete Staehling View Post
    On a side note... I checked out the Craftsman 12" bench top at Sears and was surprised to find that it seemed pretty cheaply made. Maybe it was just that the floor model was in bad shape, but there seemed to be tons of play in places that didn't look like they could be adjusted out. Has anyone checked one out lately and care to comment?
    This is what prompted my previous post. Many current drill press offerings in all price ranges are pretty shoddy. Again, a budget range would get you better responses for the best machine in your price range.

    As to older machines; my 1940's Delta/Milwaukee is head and shoulders above my 10 year old Delta but, the lack of an elegant table raising mechanism and a "metal work" type table led me to a more modern machine despite "tons of play in places that didn't look like they could be adjusted" .

    Pick your price point and then shop for the best solution in that range. Folks here can at least tell you specific machines to avoid based on experience.
    "A hen is only an egg's way of making another egg".


    – Samuel Butler

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    NW Indiana
    Posts
    3,078
    On the expensive side is the Nova Voyager DVR Drill Press. I have had mine for over a year and love it. Very little run out, 6" stroke and extremely easy to change speeds.

  12. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by glenn bradley View Post
    Pick your price point and then shop for the best solution in that range. Folks here can at least tell you specific machines to avoid based on experience.
    I resist getting boxed into choosing a price point early in the process. I sometimes find I want/need to spend on more expensive stuff and sometimes find that I am happy with Harbor Freight, Porter Cable, Wen, or whatever. I pretty much never go really high dollar. I could see myself buying a <$300 bench top model and could possibly see spending close to $1k or so. The middle and lower half of the range is more likely though. The crappy little $65 HF drill press actually had little to no negative impact on the quality of my work and only a moderate impact on productivity. On the other hand I do use it multiple times every day.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    SoCal
    Posts
    22,494
    Blog Entries
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by Pete Staehling View Post
    I resist getting boxed into choosing a price point early in the process. I sometimes find I want/need to spend on more expensive stuff and sometimes find that I am happy with Harbor Freight, Porter Cable, Wen, or whatever. I pretty much never go really high dollar. I could see myself buying a <$300 bench top model and could possibly see spending close to $1k or so. The middle and lower half of the range is more likely though. The crappy little $65 HF drill press actually had little to no negative impact on the quality of my work and only a moderate impact on productivity. On the other hand I do use it multiple times every day.
    Good enough . My shop is full of a wide range of tools. I try not to spend high when not doing so will work well and leave me more cash for lumber and hardware. Things like WEN, Porter Cable and Craftsman are not much of a jump, if any, from Harbor Freight at this point in history. there are people on here who have run HF floor machines for years with good result. They just tend to not speak up because the "cool kids" talk smack about them. I say, if it works for you then , it works for you; end of discussion.

    If belt changes are your enemy, the new 12" Rikon variable speed may be interesting and Lee Valley has free shipping right now. In that same $500 tier is the Bailey 15" VS bench top but, like many DP's doesn't go slow enough for woodworking. If belt changes don't bother you (BTW, belt changes are easy on a well designed machine, I change many times during a session in the shop and don't even think about it) the 14" Griz I mentioned before would be worth a look.
    "A hen is only an egg's way of making another egg".


    – Samuel Butler

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jan 2016
    Location
    Longmont, CO
    Posts
    810
    where are you located Pete? i would search craigslist and find something. I would go for a floor model for the longer stroke. you can always cut of the column and mount the base to a bench if it suites your work better. You will get a more ridgid machine with a beefier column.

    i bought a press from the 40s and replaced all the bearings, added a 3ph 2hp motor and a VFD to it. i think i have about 600 into it but it will go from 3k rpm to just about 0 and it has a very long stroke and is very ridged. I could mill aluminum and plastics on it easily with an x y table.

    ex: denver.craigslist.org/tls/d/3-4-hp-delta-drill-press/6676932112.html

    denver.craigslist.org/tls/d/drill-press-rockwell-vs/6678370166.html

    denver.craigslist.org/tls/d/delta-20-drill-press/6660580292.html

    the rockwell is overpriced, but a nice machine. you can usually find the deltas a bit cheaper than this too, they are good canidates for 3ph motors and vfds.
    Last edited by John K Jordan; 09-02-2018 at 1:37 PM. Reason: unlink

  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by Adam Herman View Post
    where are you located Pete?
    Tallahassee, FL.
    I'll keep an eye on Craigslist. Most of what shows up here on CL is an hour or more drive from where I live, so that can be a bit of a hassle, but sometimes there are good deals close by or worth the drive.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •