First off, I know making your own hardwood flooring is regarded as a fools errand for good reason.
We are looking for 400 sq ft of floor for a bedroom addition we put on the house. We have visited Lumber Liquidators, Lowes, Home Depot, flooring stores, etc.
We both like the look of a face nailed floor with tremont nails like was done in colonial times. I'm wondering what the true purpose of the tongue and groove on modern flooring is? Is it just to provide a place for the blind nailing, or does it also keep it from buckling during seasonal changes?
I have a 12" Crescent Joiner, 18" Oliver Planer, and an Oliver 232. I can get Ash from my local yard for $1.60 and my equipment can crank out 400 sq ft of boards no problem but I definitely don't have the time to rout tongue and groove on them.
It will only be us in the bedroom so I'm not too worried about some seasonal gaps, I just wonder how bad it will be. I'm also worried about counter sinking all the nails before renting a flooring sander. That sounds like a real pain. It seems like most of the info I found online is about face nailing tongue and grooved wide plank flooring to prevent cupping but not using it as the primary fastening system.