Originally Posted by
David Kumm
This isn't directly on point but I can't let it go either. A bandsaw is not a precision machine. There have been no real improvements in bandsaws since the invention of ball bearings and AC motors. They are simple and depend entirely on materials used and quality of build. Unlike some other machines, newer saws are not a bargain in comparison to old. I ran an ACM LT18 which is higher end than either of the saws discussed here but it was mediocre in comparison to my Y20 made in 1938. Wheel balance and frame strength ( including the build of the tension spring mechanism ) are the primary factors that determine a good quality saw. Age is only relevant if the machine was marginal when new as are guides if the saws tensions high enough. Dave