Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 31 to 45 of 57

Thread: Reasons for Festool vs. Fein Dust Extractor

  1. #31
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    NE Connecticut
    Posts
    695
    Quote Originally Posted by Malcolm Schweizer View Post
    Tis has been an enlightening thread. The things I learned:
    - Festool vacs require a bag. I didn't know this. So glad I did not buy one, as that would be a hassle.
    - The Fein will hold systainers according to a YouTube video I watched after reading this thread.
    - Festool is succeptable to static discharges.

    This is thread has made me want a Fein. My Ridgid is doing me just fine for now, but if it ever dies I will get a Fein.
    My Fein has a bag. Not sure if it's required or not (don't much care since it came with one and I have a Dust Deputy to catch almost everything before it gets into the bag), but thought you should know before settling on a Fein.


  2. #32
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Toronto Ontario
    Posts
    11,247
    Quote Originally Posted by Malcolm Schweizer View Post
    Tis has been an enlightening thread. The things I learned:
    - Festool vacs require a bag. I didn't know this. So glad I did not buy one, as that would be a hassle.
    - The Fein will hold systainers according to a YouTube video I watched after reading this thread.
    - Festool is succeptable to static discharges.

    This is thread has made me want a Fein. My Ridgid is doing me just fine for now, but if it ever dies I will get a Fein.
    Hi Malcolm, actually that's one of the reasons I like the Festool vac, they use a bag.

    I guess that's the industrial approach in me, if you're concerned about hazardous fine dust, you want a bag so you're not exposed to it when emptying it.

    At work we use a Dust Deputy for vacuuming dust, particularly when drilling concrete, it separates so much out that we don't change the bag more than once or twice a year....Rod.

  3. #33
    Quote Originally Posted by Rod Sheridan View Post
    Hi Malcolm, actually that's one of the reasons I like the Festool vac, they use a bag.

    I guess that's the industrial approach in me, if you're concerned about hazardous fine dust, you want a bag so you're not exposed to it when emptying it.

    At work we use a Dust Deputy for vacuuming dust, particularly when drilling concrete, it separates so much out that we don't change the bag more than once or twice a year....Rod.
    I use a bag in my Ridgid vac for the same reasons that Rod mentioned. They're not that expensive and my vac doesn't fill up that quickly - I mostly use it connected to my sanders so most of the swarf is sanding dust. Makes it much easier to dispose of the swarf and the primary filter stays clean so I get consistent vacuuming.

    Mike
    Go into the world and do well. But more importantly, go into the world and do good.

  4. One thing to note also is that the older R2D2 style Feins are reportedly a much better vac than the newer models. i don't personally have any comparison other than i have a 15ish year old R2D2 style turbo 2 and my dealer keeps telling me to hold onto it as this unit is way better than the newer models. In the hepa world and osha compliance festool is not out of line on their pricing. If you want to see some crazy pricing on a hepa rated vac take a look at the Hilti line. The model that compares to the CT36E (self cleaning fine dust model) is over 1k now. Hilti's are hepa rated and designed for concrete dust. Love my Hilti stuff as it is definitely a pro tool in terms of quality and the pricing shows it.

  5. #35
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Location
    Greensboro, NC
    Posts
    127
    I ended up getting the Fein Turbo 1 and got a HEPA filter, $388 total. Liking it very much so far, the suction with the Domino and 125 sander is great! No dust left in the mortise or on the board when sanding, can't imagine that the Festool would do any better.

    Thanks everyone for their advice and help!!

  6. #36
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Upland, CA
    Posts
    1,344
    The suction power will be very similar. The advantages of the Festool will be in variable suction, convenience, anti-static, stacking tools on top, etc. The HEPA cert on the Festool will be important to many commercial users.

    The calibrated air leak for variable suction on the new Feins is just one reason why I wouldn't replace on of my older Feins with the new models. The Festools are easily worth the price difference to some buyers. The Ridgid 1450 is great for others. Sounds like you have a reasonable compromise for your needs.

  7. #37
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    Doylestown, PA
    Posts
    7,551
    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Becker View Post
    From a general functional perspective, either machine is great for the job. The Festool is the better choice if you want/need to "embrace the system", such as being able to attach Festool systainers and other accommodations on top of the extractor or utilize the hose-garage feature that Festool provides. One thing...at least for the Festool, but maybe for the Fein, too, but I'm not familiar with it...I don't prefer to use this kind of vac for "shop cleanup" because of the bags and their cost. I only use my Festool extractor for off-the-tool collection. I keep a small shop vac for general cleanup (a 4 gal Ridgid in my case) since I can just dump that into the trash after a thorough shop cleanup.
    Shop Vac bags will fit the older Fein Turbo II. That's what in mine now. I don't know if the current production Fein is different.

  8. #38
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    Neither here nor there
    Posts
    3,831
    Blog Entries
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by Rod Sheridan View Post
    Hi Malcolm, actually that's one of the reasons I like the Festool vac, they use a bag.

    I guess that's the industrial approach in me, if you're concerned about hazardous fine dust, you want a bag so you're not exposed to it when emptying it.

    At work we use a Dust Deputy for vacuuming dust, particularly when drilling concrete, it separates so much out that we don't change the bag more than once or twice a year....Rod.
    I use a bag in my Ridgid vac, but my issue is that I can get Ridgid bags locally, and Festool bags I would have to order. Also the Ridgid doesn't have to use the bag if I happen to run out. What I have read about the Festool is that the bag is required for use.

  9. #39
    Quote Originally Posted by Malcolm Schweizer View Post
    I use a bag in my Ridgid vac, but my issue is that I can get Ridgid bags locally, and Festool bags I would have to order. Also the Ridgid doesn't have to use the bag if I happen to run out. What I have read about the Festool is that the bag is required for use.
    Yes, the bag is required on the Festool vac. It fills up pretty tightly and has taken me 6-12 months to fill one bag, but that's just for sanders. I recently used it when flatten a couple of slabs with a router sled. Mostly, I was hoping it would pick up the fine dust and it did a pretty good job. Then the vac suddenly stopped working. The bag was chock full, the first time I let it fill that far. I've even used it to pick up drywall dust from a pole sander. I thought that would clog the bag but it didn't.
    “Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness..." - Mark Twain

  10. #40
    I have a Festool CT36 HEPA, Fein Turbo 1, and Nilfisk Attix 8 converted to HEPA.

    IMHO, for woodworking: 1. nilfisk (good ergos, good power, relatively quiet, more refined, multiple layers of safeties); 2. Fein (more power, still quiet, more tougher, poor ergonomics and hose storage) 3. Festool (weaker real life power than the nilfisk, more audible--since noise is at higher register, well thought out stacking system).

    If you're not extremely stacked for space (need to clip in systainers on your vac, or carry a Mirka Deros on your vac), I personally think the Fein is best.


    For overall wet/dry utility and severe abusive use, I think my Fein is best. Two weeks ago, a leak came because my neighbor clogged the pipes. The Nilfisk would have about 60% of the suction of the fein, not hold as much water (due to hose position), and make an annoying alert sound if the airflow went below a certain level. The Fein soldered on...after maybe an hour of severe abuse, the motor would shut down to cool off. The festool stayed in the back like the drawer queen it is.

    Personally, I'd recommend getting a used FEIN with variable suction and auto start---they go cheap, and are better than the new ones. Or you can get a Nilfisk with variable suction and auto start--they are sometimes made for other brands too.

    IMHO, the Festool is best thought of as a portable systainer cart that has a functional hepa vacuum attached.

    Btw, I'm not bashing the Festool at all. I pull out my festool ct36 (along with my tool systainers) when I need to have a break and do woodworking behind my office. It works extremely well as a convenient portable tool workshop of sorts when paired with a portable work bench.

  11. #41
    I forgot to mention that Nilfisk confusingly has multiple options of the same vac:
    Plain/ Tool triggered/ Tool trigger with auto clean/ Tool trigger with manual clean (my version).
    All have variable suction.

    The cheaper versions tend to be Plain (like for Stihl).
    Makita has the Tool trigger with autoclean.
    Mirka has the tool trigger with manual clean (most useful IMO, since the autoclean can result in bad things when you use a sander with the vac).

  12. #42
    Festool has updated their vacs. They have strengthened the hose garage and designed a new hose. The new hose is smooth on the outside with no ridges to catch on the edge of tables or boards. No release date for North America has been announced yet.

  13. #43
    FWIW, even though I may sound like a Festool basher, I'm a huge fan of how they implement their ergonomics and organization. As a hobbyist, I just can't justify too many of their tools when I can find something cheaper that works as well (Makita track saw, Nilfisk/Fein vac), better (Mirka Deros), or build something better (Paulk workbench).

    Maybe I should save up for their router? The dust collection seems pretty sweet.

  14. #44
    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Location
    SE PA - Central Bucks County
    Posts
    65,685
    Matt, I do have to say that the dust collection on the OF1400 has been really good and with multiple options for collection, depending on the job at hand, it's flexible, too.
    --

    The most expensive tool is the one you buy "cheaply" and often...

  15. #45
    Thanks for the tip. Any thoughts on the OF1010?

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •