Originally Posted by
Bill Sutherland
I told him most of what I make is small boxes but also most of what I do will be resawing. He feels that enjoyment factor is so enjoyable and different from lesser saws I will be glad to have spent the money. I'm wondering if there is really THAT much difference. He lives far from me or I'd just go see for myself.
You are leaning over into what I consider a value assessment which is different for everyone. The 14" steel spined saws will all likely get you here you are going, the larger saws add speed and capacity. I think one of the most important things for each individual is deciding on a reasonable budget and doing their best to work within it. It is easy to get caught in budget creep (or budget landslide) on internet forums and "bigger, stronger, faster, better" is always intriguing but it isn't always the best choice for everyone and the work they do. I like bandsaws, it has really been a hobby within a hobby for me I buy bandsaws just to experience them and then sell them on unless they warrant a more permanent place. 75% of what I do on a bandsaw could be done on a Delta with a riser and a 1.5hp motor a much higher percentage with an Asian import 17/18" saw with 2hp. I do identify the idea of "pleasure to use" and I suppose it is a little like Festool vs Dewalt in that one has to decide how much "pleasure" is worth. Just listening to you in the thread I have a feeling that one of the good 14" saws would work out very well for you.
Of all the laws Brandolini's may be the most universally true.
Deep thought for the day:
Your bandsaw weighs more when you leave the spring compressed instead of relieving the tension.