Originally Posted by
David C. Roseman
Jay, you’re getting some thoughtful advice in this thread. After much research two years ago considering all the full-sized lathes, I went with the Grizzly G0733. I’m very happy with it. A number of my turning friends have the Jet 1642EVS, also a very good lathe, especially with the 2 hp motor. I recently watched Kerry Harrison’s (owner of Harrison Specialties) YouTube video mentioned above by others, comparing the two machines. Here are a few thoughts based on my experience.
Chuck fit:
The G0733 and Jet 1642 both have 1-1/4” x 8 spindle threads, so will accept all chucks with inserts machined to that size. However, the G0733 has a boss machined to a metric dimension on the inboard side of the spindle’s shoulder that is a few thousandths too large for some chuck inserts to seat fully against the shoulder. Some fit just fine, but Vicmarcs, Oneways, and possibly some others, are too tight. The Jet lathe does not have this boss (as Kerry Harrison notes in his video), and one isn’t really needed. It’s my understanding that a boss on a shaft is typically to help register a fitting when it’s being threaded on, and to add some reinforcement, and that’s not necessary on these lathes.
Kerry says in the video that he can still use his Vicmarc chuck on his G0733 without it seating squarely against the shoulder while he considers another solution. This is a bad idea, IMO, as it can lead to major seizing of the chuck insert on the boss (a big problem), and also can cause runout.
But there is a very easy fix for this on the G0733. As Roger Chandler describes above in his post, just take a mill file and hold it against the spindle boss with the lathe on low speed until it’s turned down a few thousandths of an inch. It takes about 15 minutes, if you work carefully. The final diameter of the boss is not critical, so long as it’s not too tight, of course. Voila, all the 1-1/4” x 8 chucks seat flush to the spindle shoulder, no problem. Grizzly should get on the stick and fix this issue with some instructions to the Asian factory.
Fit and finish:
I’m quite pleased with the fit and finish on my G0733. Before I bought it, I looked at one pretty carefully on the showroom floor at Grizzly in Muncy, PA , and the lathe I unpacked was just as nice. Is it as good as the finish on a Jet 1642? I think so, but that’s just my subjective impression.
Kerry Harrison in his video mentioned that the inside edges of the cast iron bed ways on the G0733 are not chamfered. I checked mine out of curiosity, and they, too, are not. But they are nicely radiused, and smooth. If there were any roughness, I would just dress it off lightly with a fine mill file. The top surfaces of the bed ways are nicely machined and very smooth.
Kerry also noted in video that the spindle pulley access door on the Jet 1642 uses thumb knob, while the G0733 has a machine screw. I like a knob, so just made my own by imbedding the head of the screw in a small piece of maple with five-minute epoxy. I slipped a piece of 1/8” vinyl tubing over the threads, chucked it into a drill chuck, and turned a custom knob in a few minutes. I actually prefer it to a plastic knob.
Lack of a Hand Wheel on the G0733:
The lack of an outboard hand wheel on the G0733 was actually a pretty big negative for me when shopping for a lathe. The hand wheel on the Jet is more of a narrow cylinder than what I would call a hand wheel, but it’s nice and certainly does the job. I only went ahead with the Grizzly after determining that I could make my own, and integrate it with a shop-made vacuum adapter for vacuum chucking. That’s worked out very well, so I now have a combination hand wheel/integrated vacuum adapter that stays on the lathe and still lets me use the knockout bar. It uses the two threaded holes in the spindle pulley that are designed to receive a pulley puller. Last July I wrote up a tutorial on doing this for owners of G0733s and other similar Asian-made 18-47 lathes. If you end up with the G0733, I’d be happy to send you a copy if you’d like to do that.
The Variable Frequency Drive (Inverter):
There is another difference in the G0733 and the Jet 1642VS that hasn’t been mentioned. It’s the way the variable frequency drive (VFD) is set up. The G0733 uses a Delta Electronics VFD-M series drive, enclosed by a nice steel cover. But it does not come standard with a braking resistor. The last time I checked, the 1642VS,as well as Jet’s PM 3520B, uses the slightly less expensive Delta Electronics VFD-S-1 drive, with no protective cover, but adds a braking resistor. While a braking resistor is not at all necessary to full performance of the G0733, it’s a nice feature to have when swinging large bowls, etc. It harnesses electromagnetic energy to bring the lathe to a stop more quickly at shut down. So you can work a bit quicker, especially if you’re in production (which I’m not!). I’m also told by electrical engineers who know these things that it can extend motor life over a long period of service.
I added a braking resistor to our G0733 for about $30 all in, but that required making up a special wiring interface, unlocking the VFD through its communications port with a laptop (adjustment of the drive parameters is locked out at the lathe factory), and getting help from a couple of buddies who have the electronics savvy to do it. I doubt most owners would want to bother with this for the relatively small benefit. BTW, Grizzly could easily add an OEM braking resistor as a standard item for a small increase in cost if they wished. In the meantime, Jet/Powermatic have the slight advantage here, IMO.
Hope this is helpful with your shopping decision. I don’t think you’ll go wrong with either lathe.
David