Peter, thanks for the comments. I would have thought the ebonizing solution would turn the oak a nice black all around, but the side grain left a lot to be desired. The dye I used came from a CL ad. It's a leather/fabric dye called "Blacker than Black", and only cost $0.50 for 16 oz. when bought by the case of 12 bottles!! He had other colors and a case could be of mixed colors, so a good deal for certain. Perhaps several coats of the ebonizing solution might have done the trick, but 1 coat of dye worked fine. Thanks again.