Originally Posted by
Giacomo Cheslaghi
The HD logo is a clear example, but there must be a way to protect myself anytime I engrave, for example, a photo.
I cannot possibly know if the photo of a cute cat the customer gave me is of his cat or the first price winner of an International Cat Show, so there must be a limit after which I'm not held responsible for infringement of any copyright...
That's because you are getting caught up in non-sense. You realize people have been talking about this copy-write nonsense for generations, right? Finding the original source of some web image or any image is near impossible. It's a waste of time. You just have to use discretion.
Using a HD logo on 2-3 trophies for "The Best Harley" at a motorcycle show is illegal. At the same time, you are not selling the award because it has HD's name on it. The customer would buy it anyway. You are just using their logo to identify it is in fact for a HD. Copy-write/trademark infringement? Yes. Does it matter? No.
The difference is if you went and started making "Harley Davidson" based merchandise. Taking a mug and just engraving the HD logo or making a pen set with just the HD logo. Then you are marketing something as Harley Davidson swag and that is blatant copy-write infringement and shows poor ethics.
Although the issue is the same, quantity and market presence is your biggest concern as the engraver. 10 HD pens for a small bike club is one thing. 10,000 for a give-away for a bike club is another. One award with the HD logo for a bike show is one thing. It's another if you are going to take a picture of the award and post it on a piece of marketing material or the web and distribute it to increase revenue.
Equipment: IS400, IS6000, VLS 6.60, LS100, HP4550, Ricoh GX e3300n, Hotronix STX20
Software: Adobe Suite & Gravostyle 5
Business: Trophy, Awards and Engraving