1 Attachment(s)
Henry Taylor Roughing Gouge: 2 Brand New, 2 Different Lengths?
I ordered from Lee Valley a 1-12" roughing gouge. It arrived with a loose ferrule. I ordered another one, (and was waiting for the replacement to have a suitable box to return the first for refund).
New one doesn't have a loose ferrule, but it is about 3/4" less steel on the tool.
Attachment 441898
Is that much variance normal for Henry Taylor products? Or, is this is something that shouldn't have made it through quality control and I've got an undersized tool for my money (Which at about $150.00 isn't a cheapie)
The 1 1/2" gouge is 22 1/4" long overall with a 5" blade.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jim Barkelew
That looks like what a hand made process may produce. What does the web site say the flute length is? This may be the stated tolerance for the length. It may be you got a extra long one for the price of a short one. Or the short one is a return after many re-sharpenings. I'd sent the short one back and use thin CA glue to fix the loose ferrule. Both company's have a good reputation . You may be the first user to have 2 new gouges to compare the lengths.
Jim
The web site indicates "The 1 1/2" gouge is 22 1/4" long overall with a 5" blade."
I agree, I'd send the short one back. I'd also send them the photo and ask them if the short one is the new official length. Maybe take a photo with the ruler positioned from the ferrules better showing the length. If it's a mistake, they might want to know. If it's the new length, we might want to know.
I personally like a longer roughing gouge when I'm turning large spindles - it gives more flexibility for positioning the tool and tool rest, especially when angling the tool.
JKJ