The right to repair my green monster

  1. Gary Hensley
    Gary Hensley
    The right to repair your equipment is in the news lately, with people asking Congress to make it easier. The cost of a new VSD @ $1500.00 is eye-opening when I have seen them for 20 percent of that value. New drives come with a manual that explains each parameter and gives various typical settings. I have a background in VSD's from work(retired electronics technician / large pharmaceutical company), so after I purchased my Grizzly G0733, I gathered information so I could replace my VSD. I made a presentation at our local wood-turners club about VSD repair and replacement, and was openly criticized by multiple people because of that presentation. I understand copyright infringement, but isn't that what I did every day at my old job, replacing, repairing and reprogramming electronic equipment myself instead of buying the "off the shelf" version? Am I the bad guy because I choose to learn how my or my former employer's equipment worked?
  2. Roger Chandler
    Roger Chandler
    I think its great you know how to repair/replace/program a VFD. I don’t understand why any woodturner would criticize that. Glad you’re a part of the GGMG, as we need knowledgeble folks who can help members with issues when they might arise. I hope you will have a willingness to give others guidance when thy get stuck. David Roseman has a G0733 and has done some programming of hiis VFD, and others who have had a need to add a braking resistor,etc.
  3. Brice Rogers
    Brice Rogers
    Good that you can repair your VFD yourself.

    I googled "can a person use copyrighted material for personal use" and noted the following: "Personal use is when an individual uses a copyrighted work for private purposes, such as learning or entertainment. Personal use is a right given in the Copyright Clause of the U.S. Constitution, however, an issue arises when the individual wants to make a copy of the copyrighted work". Also, the underlying issue depends on what was copyrighted.

    Another Google search on "Can PLC parameters be copyrighted?" yielded the following: "The copyright of the finished PLC program is almost certainly owned by the customer, not the integrator. "

    But I'm not an attorney, am not giving legal advice, so those are just my own opinions.
Results 1 to 3 of 3