Black Locust Burl HollowForm (pics)

[George Guadiane]

This burl came from an undisclosed roadside right of way in Westchester County NY. I looked at the stump that it was left on for 2 winters (it disappeared into the foliage in the summer). Spring a year ago, I brought my chainsaw into NY City with me and "liberated" the burl.
The wood was SO nice, that I went back another time and cut closer to the bone, to get the last little bits for a pen turning friend.
I'm sure it's black Locust because when I went back, there was a new sprout, CLEARLY BL.
I turned one larger piece, and sold the bowl right away... I am selling (I hope) at the same show, this weekend. I am hoping that the customer wants another piece of this VERY rare wood.

You may notice the inset neck... I wanted to try something a little different, and this is what I came up with.



Diameter: 6 1/2 inches
Height: 4 1/4 inches
Finish: Oil sanded to 600
Questions, Comments and Critique Welcome
And I CAN handle the truth!

[Don Orr]

Very nice George-awesome wood and the shape really did it justice.!

[Mike A. Smith]

Beautiful work George, wonderful display of some great wood. The neck is really interesting and creative, I like it a lot! If I had to pick on something, I would have preferred something a little 'plainer' on the foot. Maybe a single ring or even just a small concave. Just a personal preference and I'm still one of the new guys around here so take it with a grain of salt. What you've done there is way beyond my skill level!

[George Guadiane]

Beautiful work George, wonderful display of some great wood. The neck is really interesting and creative, I like it a lot! If I had to pick on something, I would have preferred something a little 'plainer' on the foot. Maybe a single ring or even just a small concave. Just a personal preference and I'm still one of the new guys around here so take it with a grain of salt. What you've done there is way beyond my skill level!
See, THAT is really funny...
I used to do plainer feet (I liked them better myself), but I got an award at our last "Totally Turning Symposium," and the one "negative" comment that Beth Ireland (one of the judges) was said to have made is that the foot was too plain (it was a segmented piece). I had also heard Stewart Beatty and a couple of other demonstrators talk about that "nice little surprise" of a fancier foot when someone picks up your work and examines the bottom, so I tried this instead.
I have become comfortable with it for now.
A good friend and expert turner I know just has a cupped bottom, I don't think he even sands or finishes the bottom, just a clean cutoff. And he sells LOTS of turnings. So, like you saids, it's just another grain of salt in the shaker, but it still adds flavor! I appreciate your input. I would have agreed with you 6 months ago, and may see things that way again.

[Paul Engle]

I like all of it George, great shape, foot, inside collar, finish . spot on work keep it up :D

[Steve Schlumpf]

Great looking hollow form George! Beautiful wood, form and finish! I also like the detail work on the foot. It's simple and doesn't subtract from the form or the burl. Very nice work!

[Tom Sherman]

George that is a top shelf piece. I haven't decided on bottom treatments yet tend to make what ever strikes me at the time.

[Mike A. Smith]

See, THAT is really funny...
I used to do plainer feet (I liked them better myself), but I got an award at our last "Totally Turning Symposium," and the one "negative" comment that Beth Ireland (one of the judges) was said to have made is that the foot was too plain (it was a segmented piece). I had also heard Stewart Beatty and a couple of other demonstrators talk about that "nice little surprise" of a fancier foot when someone picks up your work and examines the bottom, so I tried this instead.
I have become comfortable with it for now.
A good friend and expert turner I know just has a cupped bottom, I don't think he even sands or finishes the bottom, just a clean cutoff. And he sells LOTS of turnings. So, like you saids, it's just another grain of salt in the shaker, but it still adds flavor! I appreciate your input. I would have agreed with you 6 months ago, and may see things that way again.

This is one of those really subjective things. My problem is I'm an absolute wood junkie. When you guys that have the skill get hold of some of these great pieces of wood I would be just as happy if you turned a perfect sphere and put it on a turntable!

[George Guadiane]

This is one of those really subjective things. My problem is I'm an absolute wood junkie. When you guys that have the skill get hold of some of these great pieces of wood I would be just as happy if you turned a perfect sphere and put it on a turntable!
Thanks Everyone,
Mike,
That's why I make so many hollow forms, the wood is usually pretty on ALL sides, so I try to get as much of the surface to show as I can.
If slabs of beautiful wood would sell, I whould probably just cut and finish them myself :eek:

[Bernie Weishapl]

George I like it. I also like the foot. I like mine to be decorative. I was told in a e-mail from Cindy Drozda that you want to make a foot that will catch someones eye because the first thing they look at is the bottom.

[Allen Neighbors]

George I think you've got a nice piece here. I like the way you inset the top... it's just enough to add some mystery to an already wonderful piece. I like Southwestern forms, and this seems like one to me. Rare piece of wood, and you've done it justice. Well Done.

[Ed Scolforo]

George, that's a good looking hollow form! I like the foot also.

[Joseph Peacock]

Very nice Mr.George!!!!!!!!!!!!!:D ;) :cool:

[Curt Fuller]

That's a nice looking hollowform. I personally like the foot or any other type of enhancements that add a little interest to the piece without overwelming the beauty in the wood. I really like the inset opening. It's something I haven't seen before. And it's a very nice piece of wood.

[Terry Quiram]

Black Locust is one of my favorite woods to turn. When dry it is very hard and it takes a long time to get to finished size. But BL finishes so well and a thin wall bowl still has some "heft" to it. I really like making finger tops from BL. I have not found a burl yet but after seeing this piece I will double my efforts. Well done.

Terry

[George Guadiane]

Thank ALL of you for your kind words and opinions.
I hope that if you don't like something I do, in the future, that you are as willing to chime in. I still need the feedback.
G

[Ken Fitzgerald]

George .....there is nothing to dislike about this HF! Form, finish, execution......Nicely done sir!