PDA

View Full Version : 20" Planer Feed Qestion - trouble feeding large boards



Sean Moore
10-26-2022, 9:45 PM
I have a Laguna 20" Planer, one of the newer PX20 models, and have noticed it is having trouble feeding larger boards. Smaller pieces are fine, but I recently had to plane down some 10/4 ash that is 6" wide and 72" long. I have to push the boards through with a decent amount of pressure and then pull them out on the other side in order for it to feed. If I dont touch the board it wont move. Same goes for some 8/4 walnut that is similarly sized. Im taking a fairly small cut, maybe 1/32 or 1/16" max.

Is it normal to have to help feed boards of that size through a machine, or do I need to go in and make adjustments to the feed rollers? The machine is 5hp, but I have no relative experience with other planers of this size.

Mike Cutler
10-26-2022, 10:43 PM
No, you shouldn’t need to push and pull material through your planer.
Those are not large material pieces you’re referring to. A 5hp planer should easily b handle them.
Check the settings of your pressure rollers and feed rollers.
These are jointed boards, correct?

Mel Fulks
10-26-2022, 11:04 PM
It could be just low grade knives. I’ve seen it before. Some planers are sold with low grade knives that leave a lot of striations . If you see
non -shiny wood surface and striation on newly planed wood,buy some T-1 or M2 knives and use the original junk on some free fine wood
that is full of grit ,and perhaps, a nail or two.

Greg Quenneville
10-27-2022, 3:27 AM
And ensure that the tables are well waxed. Planers are sensitive to too much friction on the tables.

Bradley Gray
10-27-2022, 4:17 AM
A late model like yours should have a manual available. Check bed rollers, in and out feed rollers and pressure bar.

Also, run the piece left, right and center. On some planers you need to raise the pressure bar while running a board.

Steve Jenkins
10-27-2022, 4:44 AM
And ensure that the tables are well waxed. Planers are sensitive to too much friction on the tables.

THIS. Most times waxing the table solves the problem. As in most things try the simplest first.

Ron Citerone
10-27-2022, 8:02 AM
THIS. Most times waxing the table solves the problem. As in most things try the simplest first.

Never owned a big planer, but have had 3 smaller ones. A good waxing worked wonders for me with feeding issues, plus it costs next to nothing to try.

Mel Fulks
10-27-2022, 9:41 AM
THIS. Most times waxing the table solves the problem. As in most things try the simplest first.

Sure , It might help. BUT some of that steel is really bad stuff. You can test one of the knives against a quality knife by wrapping a cloth
around the ends to make a ‘handle’ and use the knife like a draw-knife. The good steel will slide easily through the wood. The junk knives
will not. In employments I got a couple of bosses to buy good steel by telling them that if they bought the steel I recommended ,and they
did not think it was better, I would buy it from them. They tried it and agreed it worked much better. I’m guessing that most of the knives
in new machines are rubbish grade.

Phillip Mitchell
10-27-2022, 9:55 AM
That’s not a “wide” board, especially for a 20” machine, and not something you should be fighting.

i would troubleshoot in this order -

-wax beds (consistently before use)
-confirm / check height settings of feed rollers, pressure bar, etc in relation to cutterhead - likely need a dial indicator setup to do this accurately - the manual /manufacturer should have specs on this published and available. does it have bed rollers? If so, Lower them down below bed surface
-assess quality of knife steel (and sharpness) and possibly upgrade to something of known high quality - CGG Schmidt is not a bad source, but I’m sure many here can offer multiple options.

Richard Coers
10-27-2022, 10:15 AM
If that machine has bed rollers, all these wax the table comments won't help. Once the board gets up on both rollers, it doesn't touch the table. My guess is the bed rollers are set very close to the table to reduce snipe and as suggested, the boards have not been made flat on a jointer.

Sean Moore
10-27-2022, 1:02 PM
If that machine has bed rollers, all these wax the table comments won't help. Once the board gets up on both rollers, it doesn't touch the table. My guess is the bed rollers are set very close to the table to reduce snipe and as suggested, the boards have not been made flat on a jointer.


The boards have been flattened by a jointer and my machine has a spiral cutterhead. When you say bed rollers, you mean the infeed and out feed rollers, or the roller that is underneath the board on the bed of the machine?

David Zaret
10-27-2022, 1:03 PM
And ensure that the tables are well waxed. Planers are sensitive to too much friction on the tables.

this. it's a critical thing. wax the tables often.

Mel Fulks
10-27-2022, 1:28 PM
Oops we missed it. Back to 4th grade “ reading comprehension “ I go !.

Taking the tiny cut is the problem. Take off at least 1/16th with each pass. It’s a PLANER ,NOT a sander.

Kevin Jenness
10-27-2022, 2:21 PM
Oops we missed it. Back to 4th grade “ reading comprehension “ I go !.

Taking the tiny cut is the problem. Take off at least 1/16th with each pass. It’s a PLANER ,NOT a sander.

A planer ought to feed properly with a minimal cut. If waxing the table doesn't work, look at the feed roller, chipbreaker and pressure bar setup and adjust to spec.

Warren Lake
10-27-2022, 3:02 PM
thats not accurate Richard. I run my table rollers below the table and using wax is night and day, no rollers.

Sounds like the machine is set up poorly. All set up begins from knife projection out of the head which determines the cutting circle which determines the settings of pressure rollers, feed rollers etc. There will be info in the manual of the specs on that stuff for your machine.

Mel Fulks
10-27-2022, 3:08 PM
I know the small planers take off less than 1/16th ,but all the big bigger planers I used would not do that .
Some shops even have a strict rule about that. Several reasons , of course one is killing time .

Tom Bender
11-01-2022, 7:55 AM
Clean the powered feed rollers. They can get waxy and slip. Be careful around the knives.

ChrisA Edwards
11-01-2022, 8:59 AM
I have a Hammer A3-31, 12" planer. Felder sells a product called Super Glide. When I see boards struggling to go through, a couple of spritzes on the bed, with Super Glide, and the wood feeds nicely for the next 30-40 pieces. My beds are well waxed.

One bottle lasts years.
https://www.felder-group.com/en-us/shop/lubrication-agents-sc589798/super-glide-sp589785

https://www.felder-group.com/WEB/shop/reinigungs-und-wartungsmittel/misc/spruehflasche--7c-1-stueck/image-thumb__65495__fgroup_shop_productDetail/felder_10.0.010_02@2x.jpg

Malcolm Schweizer
11-24-2022, 12:25 PM
Can we get an update on this? I am trying to decide between the Laguna and the Powermatic helical head planers. This problem you are having would concern me. I run a lot of big rough sawn lumber. Did you resolve the problem?

Bradley Gray
11-25-2022, 12:34 AM
Malcolm, I don't know the Laguna, but some of the bigger Powermatics have easily adjusted bed rollers. Raising the bed rollers will let you plane irregular stock.

Malcolm Schweizer
11-25-2022, 9:33 AM
Malcolm, I don't know the Laguna, but some of the bigger Powermatics have easily adjusted bed rollers. Raising the bed rollers will let you plane irregular stock.

Yes, I used one for years, but thought the Laguna looked like a good design. My concern now is the Laguna weighs around 1/2 what the Powermatic does. I think I will go with the tried and true old school iron with the modern helical head. They are on sale today for the same price as the Laguna.

Brent Sweet
04-23-2023, 10:34 AM
Hello all, i am currently using a 12 inch Belsaw planer which has served my father and i well since 1963 and i am looking at adding a Laguna px20 to my workshop. I am having difficulty finding info on this machine and i viewed a video on Lagunas website [px15] and the operator pushes and pulls the material through the planer. Is this to be expected? With our old Belsaw we have rarely had to do this unless wood is icy or a very heavy cut. I see Sean is having a similar problem, is that normal for a steel roller planer ? I dont use a jointer before planning and have not had that problem.

Rod Sheridan
04-24-2023, 8:28 AM
I have a Hammer A3-31, 12" planer. Felder sells a product called Super Glide. When I see boards struggling to go through, a couple of spritzes on the bed, with Super Glide, and the wood feeds nicely for the next 30-40 pieces. My beds are well waxed.

One bottle lasts years.
https://www.felder-group.com/en-us/shop/lubrication-agents-sc589798/super-glide-sp589785

https://www.felder-group.com/WEB/shop/reinigungs-und-wartungsmittel/misc/spruehflasche--7c-1-stueck/image-thumb__65495__fgroup_shop_productDetail/felder_10.0.010_02@2x.jpg

I’ve found the Felder Silber Gleit works even better.

It’s a paste that comes in a 1;Kg can, lasts a long time……Regards, Rod