John K Jordan
08-31-2021, 2:19 PM
In the thread in General Woodworking "What happened to blue Scott shop towels?", https://sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?293341-What-happened-to-blue-Scott-shop-towels&p=3139521#post3139521
Mark Mcfarlane asked if anyone noticed a differentce in Scott shop towels in the last year.
I didn't buy any a year ago but I did buy some about six years ago. As I was down do my last unopened roll I ordered some more from Amazon and compared an unopened roll from 2015 to one from 2021.
463893 463894
My quick and not scientifically-rigorous observations on the differences between the earlier and the current Scott towels:
Weight, without plastic wrap:
2015: 350 grams
2021: 315 grams
Labeling on the packaging informed a change in total product area:
2015: 4.0 sq meters
2021: 3.7 sq meters
Advertised size of each sheet:
2015: 264 mm
2021: 239 mm
Measured size of the first sheet from each roll (may not be typical):
2015: 275 mm
2021: 235 mm
I measured the thickness of a sheet from each package using a micrometer with a calibrated pressure. Both varied considerably over the sheet but both were close to the same.
The cost, bought in 30 roll quantity from AMAZON, essentially the same cost per roll for smaller rolls:
2015: $1.99 per roll adjusted for inflation, 2021 dollars
2021: $1.98 per roll
Number of sheets per roll:
2015: 55
2021: 55
Cost per advertised square meter of product:
2015: 49.8 cents adjusted for inflation, 2021 dollars
2021: 53.5 cents
It's probably a coincidence but interesting that the width of a 2021 towel is reduced by about the same percentage as the inflation since 2015.
Both indicate they are "Made in USA of U.S. and/or non-U.S. materials." "Made" could mean anything: they could buy bulk towel material made anywhere and cut, roll, and package in the US.
Softness: Neither are as soft as the paper towels I prefer for many shop tasks.
The "old" Scott towels definitely feel softer to the touch than those I received today. This is not a problem for me since I usually don't use them for applying/wiping finish. I mostly use the Scott towels around farm and vehicle equipment while changing oil, greasing the tractor and such.
So yes, Mark. I suspect Scott Brand has changed both their material and processing.
Bottom line: quality down, cost up.
Could be worse!
JKJ
Mark Mcfarlane asked if anyone noticed a differentce in Scott shop towels in the last year.
I didn't buy any a year ago but I did buy some about six years ago. As I was down do my last unopened roll I ordered some more from Amazon and compared an unopened roll from 2015 to one from 2021.
463893 463894
My quick and not scientifically-rigorous observations on the differences between the earlier and the current Scott towels:
Weight, without plastic wrap:
2015: 350 grams
2021: 315 grams
Labeling on the packaging informed a change in total product area:
2015: 4.0 sq meters
2021: 3.7 sq meters
Advertised size of each sheet:
2015: 264 mm
2021: 239 mm
Measured size of the first sheet from each roll (may not be typical):
2015: 275 mm
2021: 235 mm
I measured the thickness of a sheet from each package using a micrometer with a calibrated pressure. Both varied considerably over the sheet but both were close to the same.
The cost, bought in 30 roll quantity from AMAZON, essentially the same cost per roll for smaller rolls:
2015: $1.99 per roll adjusted for inflation, 2021 dollars
2021: $1.98 per roll
Number of sheets per roll:
2015: 55
2021: 55
Cost per advertised square meter of product:
2015: 49.8 cents adjusted for inflation, 2021 dollars
2021: 53.5 cents
It's probably a coincidence but interesting that the width of a 2021 towel is reduced by about the same percentage as the inflation since 2015.
Both indicate they are "Made in USA of U.S. and/or non-U.S. materials." "Made" could mean anything: they could buy bulk towel material made anywhere and cut, roll, and package in the US.
Softness: Neither are as soft as the paper towels I prefer for many shop tasks.
The "old" Scott towels definitely feel softer to the touch than those I received today. This is not a problem for me since I usually don't use them for applying/wiping finish. I mostly use the Scott towels around farm and vehicle equipment while changing oil, greasing the tractor and such.
So yes, Mark. I suspect Scott Brand has changed both their material and processing.
Bottom line: quality down, cost up.
Could be worse!
JKJ