PDA

View Full Version : SC3 slider blade



scott lipscomb
04-29-2020, 10:33 AM
I picked up an older SC3 slider a few months ago and have taken it apart and put it back together a few times and I finally am beginning to understand the nuances of the slider mechanism. I thought maybe some of the parts were worn (which didn't make a lot of sense to me, as the machine appears to be pretty unused), but it turns out that everything just needed adjustment. I switched out all of the bearings (which were really cheap, BTW) and I have the machine really dialed in and I am happy.

Now, I am looking for a new blade. The machine is designed for a 12" blade, and has a 5/8" arbor. The choices that I see out there are Forrest and Ridge. The Woodworker II and the 2000 are their respective combo blades. I think that these would fit the bill, though I expect that I will use the machine more for crosscutting than for ripping. I still have a PM66 set up and I actually tend to rip on my bandsaw. In 25 years, Ive launched 2 pieces, and both were panels that were nearly square, but still, I like that the SC3 has a very nice riving knife. What I don't like is to have to remove the crosscut table to rip.

I am leaning towards the 48 tooth Forrest blade. It'll cost me nearly $200, though, so I am wondering if there are any other ideas out there. Is a bushing a bad idea, or a non-issue? Any other 12"/5/8" blades out there that my internet fu is not finding? I see Amana may have some offerings, but they all look like sheet good blades and are in the same ballpark. I'd happily buy a Feud, but it doesn't look like they offer anything.

Erik Loza
04-29-2020, 11:29 AM
Regarding bushings, Amana makes them and I actually bought a packet of assorted ones from Harbor Freight that worked fine for the Italian machines. BTW, be prepared to dress the OD, ID, and possibly thickness of the bushings with some emery cloth or wet sanding paper. The bushings work fine but will require some "massaging" for perfect fit. Hope this helps.

Erik

Jim Becker
04-29-2020, 12:43 PM
I've been standard on the WW-II Blades for almost two decades. I use the 48T WW-II 12 on my S315WS slider and it's the exact width of my scoring blade, too. You can get it for a decent price from Silvers Mill for $150. https://www.sliversmill.com/product_680_12x48T_Woodworker_II_5_8_Hole__1500_OF F_Sharpening_Offer_In.html

Darcy Warner
04-29-2020, 1:12 PM
Everlast, fs tool, popular tools, etc.
Tons of way better commercial blades out there that are significantly cheaper and better than anything Forrest.

Brian W Evans
04-29-2020, 1:23 PM
I have a slider and use a WWII almost exclusively. I originally bought blades bored for 1" arbors because they were cheaper and more readily available. I use a bushing with them. I'm pretty sure my bushings are Vermont-American, which is a pretty low-rent brand. I did have to do some sanding to get the bushings to fit right, but now they work great. I recently ordered another WWII and a dado set directly from Forrest with 5/8" arbor holes, which I think might have been a slight up-charge on one of the blades.

BTW, I used my scoring blade for the first time on Tuesday and the results were AMAZING. If you've never tried it, do so immediately!

Patrick Kane
04-29-2020, 1:31 PM
I know a lot of people love the combo blades, particularly the WWII combo, but after having several different blades, it will always be dedicated blades for me. I would go as far as to say i would rather have two dedicated freud blades than a combo Forrest. 40 teeth on a 10" blade is way too many for ripping, and really not enough for crosscutting. I run two felder blades on my slider and a ridge carbide blade on my cabinet saw. After having the ridge carbide blade for a year, i severely question why i spent $150 on a top shelf ripping blade. I think Mark Bolton told me to get a cheapy last year, and i didnt listen. With the powermatic in place, id start with a great crosscutting blade on the SCM and see if you ever find yourself ripping on it.

Mark Bolton
04-29-2020, 1:46 PM
Im with Darcy, we dont spend the money on the forrest. Freud industrials are some of our go-to blades and are running some Amana's now. I run bushings on 12" blades that are bored 1" on one saw that has 5/8" arbor and while I would say its fine, there is likely a tiny bit of increased vibration but Im no nickle tester.

Have a few high dollar blades but I honestly would never see the value in a 150-200 dollar blade for much of anything but I dont cut any fine/hardwood ply or anything like that on a saw. I go for the least expensive full kerf heavy carbide blades I can find (not cheap but least expensive) that can take multiple resharps.

You'd be pretty surprised at what a good quality heavy carbide full kerf (non glue line rip) blade will produce with a decent setup. Feeder puts it over the top, but even hand fed, and especially with a slider, my help has to look real hard to figure out which is the sawn edge. Plain jane hardwood glue ups come straight off a good sharp rip blade and into glue and clamps. Now if it were a 20K conference table,.. maybe a second step with a finer blade, but day to day work, no dice.

Todd Solomon
04-29-2020, 2:49 PM
I've been standard on the WW-II Blades for almost two decades. I use the 48T WW-II 12 on my S315WS slider and it's the exact width of my scoring blade, too. You can get it for a decent price from Silvers Mill for $150. https://www.sliversmill.com/product_680_12x48T_Woodworker_II_5_8_Hole__1500_OF F_Sharpening_Offer_In.html

Thanks Jim, appreciate the lead. Do you use the WWII 48 tooth for most everything? I am about to buy for my slider, was thinking 40T. I'm lazy, hoping to leave the same blade on as much as is practical.

Jim Becker
04-29-2020, 4:59 PM
Thanks Jim, appreciate the lead. Do you use the WWII 48 tooth for most everything? I am about to buy for my slider, was thinking 40T. I'm lazy, hoping to leave the same blade on as much as is practical.

Pretty much everything. I still have my older 20T WW-II 10" ripping blade if I need to do something gnarly. I own an 80T sheet goods blade that came with my saw, but I never bothered to get it sharpened and it just sits in my blade drawer system. I keep two of the Forrest blades; one on the saw and one "out for sharpening"...which reminds me...I need to send it out. :) There are so many good blades, for sure, but again, I have stuck with the brand because I prefer the consistent tooth width which is nailed to exactly .125" and matches my scoring blade. We all have our habits... :)

scott lipscomb
05-27-2020, 8:52 PM
Thanks everyone for the help. I ordered a 48t Forrest Combo blade from Silversmill. Thanks Jim. Darcy-I checked out some industrial suppliers like you suggested, but I didn't see any combination blades, but, honestly, I didn't look that hard at them as it appears that one has to be pretty knowledgeable on the subject of saw blades to effectively navigate the choices, and, alas, I am too lazy to educate myself properly, and the Forrest seems like it fits the bill.

Mark e Kessler
05-27-2020, 10:05 PM
I am using Freud industrials, 48 atb pretty much for everything, don’t know why anyone wants a “combination” blade must be marketing... If I hadn’t got the freuds for $25 each due to an amazon screwup probably would have gone with Tenryu, fs tool...


Im with Darcy, we dont spend the money on the forrest. Freud industrials are some of our go-to blades and are running some Amana's now. I run bushings on 12" blades that are bored 1" on one saw that has 5/8" arbor and while I would say its fine, there is likely a tiny bit of increased vibration but Im no nickle tester.

Have a few high dollar blades but I honestly would never see the value in a 150-200 dollar blade for much of anything but I dont cut any fine/hardwood ply or anything like that on a saw. I go for the least expensive full kerf heavy carbide blades I can find (not cheap but least expensive) that can take multiple resharps.

You'd be pretty surprised at what a good quality heavy carbide full kerf (non glue line rip) blade will produce with a decent setup. Feeder puts it over the top, but even hand fed, and especially with a slider, my help has to look real hard to figure out which is the sawn edge. Plain jane hardwood glue ups come straight off a good sharp rip blade and into glue and clamps. Now if it were a 20K conference table,.. maybe a second step with a finer blade, but day to day work, no dice.

Jim Becker
05-28-2020, 9:36 AM
Mark, I use the "combination" blade (WW-II) because it's suitable for the majority of the cutting I do which bounces around constantly between cross cutting, ripping, working with sheet stock, etc. I'd go to a dedicated purpose blade if I was going to be doing a big job of something heavy, but for "general woodworking" switching blades is time consuming given how much variability there is in my work minute to minute. The other thing, which I previously have mentioned, is that my use of a "standard" blade for my work means my kerf is always exactly the same. There is unfortunately a large variation in kerf width across the various blade choices and brands.

Erik Loza
05-28-2020, 11:44 AM
I've used a bunch of "Combo" blades over the years (Royce/Forrest/Tenryu, and some of the German and Italian rebranded ones, plus all the usual contractor brands) and honestly, they all seemed to work fine for general-purpose use. To Jim's point, for the weekend warrior like most of us, if you find one combo blade that works well, why over-think it? Where I see woodworkers running into issues is using totally the wrong blade for the task. Like using a fine-tooth laminate blade for crosscutting wet lumber or something along those lines. If I did a lot of a laminates, then I would definitely want a dedicated laminate cutting blade (and keep the scoring blade adjusted just for that) but for all-purpose use, I've never had a problem with good quality combo blades. Just my 2-cents.

Erik

Todd Solomon
05-28-2020, 1:50 PM
Thanks everyone for the help. I ordered a 48t Forrest Combo blade from Silversmill. Thanks Jim. Darcy-I checked out some industrial suppliers like you suggested, but I didn't see any combination blades, but, honestly, I didn't look that hard at them as it appears that one has to be pretty knowledgeable on the subject of saw blades to effectively navigate the choices, and, alas, I am too lazy to educate myself properly, and the Forrest seems like it fits the bill.

I did too. I picked up a Forrest 10" 48T that I can use with my scoring blade, plus a 12" 30T for a bunch of thick rips that I will be doing on my next project. You will be very happy with the WWII, exceptional blades.

Mark e Kessler
05-28-2020, 2:11 PM
Jim, Eric

Guess I never had the need for a combo blade as a well made ATB cuts well in all applications, the only time I swap blades is if I have a critical xcut and then I use a 120t ATB, or if i have a ton of ripping (8/4 and above) to do then a 28t ATB they all have the same kerf (for now anyways). if I cut laminate or melamine I would probably go with a neg hook TCB grind.

At one time when I had a cabinet saw I tried a combo blade and didn’t like it in fact I found myself switching more often then just sticking with an atb. However it wasn’t a forrest so maybe that was the issue. I did have a Forrest high atb and it cut melamine with virtually no tear out but it screamed, I couldn’t even use it it was so loud, i gave it away with the saw when I sold it.

Jim Becker
05-28-2020, 9:03 PM
Mark, I think maybe terminology may be getting in the way. The Forrest WW-II is an ATB blade. It has a relatively steep angle on the corners which scores the edge of the cut nicely. I'm calling it a "combo" because it's perfectly well suited to both cross cutting and ripping unless the ripping is really thick and gnarly. It cuts sheet goods really clean, too, and matches the width of my scoring blade exactly for when I choose to employ it. I'm using a 48t 12" blade on my slider which is similar in performance to a 40t 10" blace.

Mark e Kessler
05-28-2020, 11:08 PM
ahh, if I would have bothered to go to the Forrest website I would have seen that it was an ATB. When i read combo I was thinking ATB-R, where there is a Raker every 4th or 5th tooth (something like that). I see that the Forrest is a 20deg where as the Freuds industrials I am using are 15 deg, it’s hard for me to know how well my blade are actually cutting as i am having vibration issues with my saw but i would think that there might be some improvement with a 20 deg over the 15 but may not stay sharp as long but who knows too many variables...

thatnks for the clarification...


Mark, I think maybe terminology may be getting in the way. The Forrest WW-II is an ATB blade. It has a relatively steep angle on the corners which scores the edge of the cut nicely. I'm calling it a "combo" because it's perfectly well suited to both cross cutting and ripping unless the ripping is really thick and gnarly. It cuts sheet goods really clean, too, and matches the width of my scoring blade exactly for when I choose to employ it. I'm using a 48t 12" blade on my slider which is similar in performance to a 40t 10" blace.

Jim Becker
05-29-2020, 9:09 AM
There are advantages to an ATB-R for ripping as well as for cutting grooves. But I really like how the ATB slices through the material and just deal with cleaning up the bottom of things that I've "nibbled" after the fact. If you want to try the WW-II blade, Silvers Mill that I mentioned above is about the best source I've found relative to price. I think you have a Felder machine if my memory serves, and if so, the do come pre-bored for your machine including the pin holes.

jack duren
05-29-2020, 10:04 AM
Is this the light green or similiar SCM Saw with the American 5/8 arbor? If it is it was suggested as the saw was bought new from the manufacturer NOT to use this saw for ripping hardwoods..We did not but a few years later it was dismantled and sold. One of the guys put there said I could get it for $600 but when I called in was told $1000. So I passed....

Jim Becker
05-29-2020, 2:00 PM
Jack...

https://www.scmgroup.com/website/var/tmp/image-thumbnails/20000/27230/thumb__SCM-imgProdotto/746-minimax-sc-3c_2017@2x.jpeg