How to Hide Ray Fleck in White Oak

[John Goodin]

I am making newel posts out of rift-sawn white oak. Frequently, ray flecks are exposed after re-sawing or planing. The plan is to stain it a dark color for a more modern look and would like to hide the ray fleck. Is there a process to down play or complete hide it? Thanks.

[Jamie Buxton]

Those long tracks on white oak only show up when the lumber face is almost exactly quartersawn. If you get just a little off quartersawn, you only get the riftsawn look. You can often choose a rift- or quartersawn board out of a stack by looking at the end of the board.

[John Goodin]

Thanks. Unfortunately the boards are painted on the end. It turns out the lumberyard has a fair amount of rift sawn that could be used for quartersawn. I was trying to buy 6/4 and resaw it to save a little money but today when I opened the split board it was full of ray fleck. I might be better off just spending a bit more and going with 4/4.

[Art Mann]

Have you considered red oak? Depending on the tree and drying, red and white oak are indistinguishable but for the ray fleck.

[Jim Becker]

Have you considered red oak? Depending on the tree and drying, red and white oak are indistinguishable but for the ray fleck.
I find these two variants to be visibly different colors, so mixing them might require some extra work during coloration if there is adjacent material. Bare white oak to me has a more "greenish" cast while red oak has a more "pinkish" cast to my eyes.

[John Goodin]

What I am really after is the rift grain pattern of the of the oak. I think it looks great with a dark stain -- more so than closed grain wood options. I think just working with the 4/4 where I can select one good surface may be the best option.

[Steve Schoene]

Use dye not a pigmented stain.

[Scott T Smith]

True rift oak (growth rings 30 - 60 degrees relative to the face) rarely has medullary ray fleck. It’s also not commonly available in wider boards.

Why don’t you just source some true rift?

[John TenEyck]

As Steve said, dyes or dye stains will minimize the ray flecks. Here's a photo or two of a couple of rift sawn WO pieces I made. There were a few ray flecks in a couple of the boards, and I had to use them because I had no extra. My very particular customer had no complaints.

I used SW's BAC Wiping Stain. Dye + stain in one easy to use, non-grain raising, fast drying product. SW has quite a few standard colors, but will custom tint them, too, for no extra charge.

Before finishing:

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/s_bjztg4MwjLhCscPe_AovTNi4SBsfGn0iVr4A1AkAHqju5kOf pbpQRfY5ev8NGknhQ67MvUzKB1AIwZQmUCRZi11QDvBivK9CXM z5lFPYU6WnwN8HBSlCT1S-k-GcrFRIV0cBDUxNg8m4fJ57eqOqm8nZ6QiLJhfaueBXbgAzwmfq 6Tn7g4HQaGmeVgMZ6fdDyLG74VlGQx81LLCSYeTNV6ZLVj077c 5K1safY9dayE7fZYkvGSNpSP0gFt2-IMuktglj6ECoF0CWbbRVnzLCwXiIqLouOCOAxeDLsVWO8mIJB3 30fszUxU4jIdy5MFkuy-tR3lueYzn7s2QL6r3uPcFWG1vYrwNtQ9WMsijdbMf4dWVANEh8 2isqS3lAXppeL-7gpACqaoQET2kOx6lKFImvW3mevKJ_uBIXeEAkffH-J0A_GXqyc5lTRhjvGGHjHHNb3PLkhy6I0JgKPZurMVsUp6ruKr n1hsuNQ0VjrMhcMymwgYnd-cZ5G3oDpHxvk8DhztKf7hAHmCzgvO_ibAK42wQehgZmFFuTor1 Ms9dDgz7qTsUqWH9YsAfa_3hXsriR8aa1AfEh_U9_cu8NQd9Ck ooym4GNZYD1KkRrmKMk0kLZsIyZt0iQp1f6KOWBZHtUquR5c_Y 9MIGpzGchoDfPGf7qhRO4sMgYY-XoRMyyRhijIZ9D7OEHF_JU_7oKdRI9DgZrSreXrCWRG7XqHEpA =w835-h626-no

After:

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/W3SuQDt6VEUAab9x8HQXSMlW_16Qu1Z-tyGA0Gu4eWlaMjJfIdi-WlbeMRdi68N36m2mmwKRalCbtrpV6JtGhjvzF6RVHpT5EA8fGA Yrkw-BKbfrFHPyBSbZy50wEttw9dbcpuMibmqjFUCprFDCfCuxOC8FF 1ID3AUfVTJIFW4rF24k4_XopeiKY65qTErPaBollSkHEpsTjpd noCKZvhoIfMG0gKAL-86HOKRPRvP2qp-JuQq6k1tfZ-Uau9Y-en-p8UzMCEFZ5IYMbh-la2w5eyrPdTv_tdI2OLt6eLczvgDLwafkOUKykWxpP_XdP3dkl vxYILlUhBCZj1exwxQWEcmdlkR1InRCsjxxcP0cDREigDUxtku slhqvY_s4Yb44TTIxXm_qghSEMkUejeiULmyYyaKkej6e61xRz aL6ZALZzUWvCuogmAZ01ZEGbhobsGK171SpCDbRzIcXZ19Z_qE sXuzcRn_Dlmj4cWSekQrHX10fGrg0aSbUdFe5LodsrQQgoRRtH RfoYZJ6PgFKLlmTUPgHeTLdfANjx3neUGnImAsiJbmCQsnlclf 9QvhlBb7Dm1tHclzhNhDU_MqZWiuGmC8bLHdoYSCtPx9YxTPo2 gWo1TcBad2UZ-CPk6EW_aAbO_3F_gz12C1TiER5mJJznmiHvpvg0KbqejtuNInu DZ3zHkFyL9aDeJBzU-aS_riNi-KwvcUiOeJH9lKq_A=w835-h626-no

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/F3Gqd-Zb7BoUkRxy_inmaqB0fEGsSCrM9wqEJhWfR8etxcsTVtFf0Whz-H4ogWqx94JQJJ3Fd0y65TC96K2U4lHr7bi8m1iarWZTgtCUv-Iw67OjqE7D2FmdSRO-Cp5bTo9FNZRnOdRVHSDw2fjJWFZ0dHD-q0j-YOa3_j7a0isGeKDQCITj2LftfaZg2DSogGN3aSx8efvKsyjx71 8MfBI2zPGspTJ_D5fD5xrvftiWJiOsBOE6jMQcvKkciLfLgCgI udRlrZ88XshPXmwQyWwZLXbM8ZMJ6pJtysHOAgIv0nuhccFD6z LqWMUdGyeqkQg2Ijr3ePmFZudd8J6VhIbeX0JYVdKrQPqz6Oa_ eTP1QDGrkc_RykZTLYzXqMyVbmobZ0FqIeuVuAukfSsrbLWz71 HNmF6D4imhAoInrngekwivOIpowQb8V3Hs8UfCoRBr3mYdHbFb JN5sQBqpJVJEtW_o1vgy5--8QYyGyYyEJoucr_nr6HAMvh8rra2H6O4pnjS-Vvg31cdl0_Rhi8XM-Z7qAGbqnSYfR4a_MocLI1W9IVEH2q6JVW1xz_SmnNb8ymcZ5hO iJuzTczibvLhHwGWxxL19ToHoZ5PrAwPpYB6VvBuj2qTzxgSoR N255Y1rwVr9Y6LTKJNjKYbQYNj59bvaOKUvx-GNd1ZvP633ieXYvYBj6HZEn5waSLjTSinApddDZUEulQHYMhBT dooZTA=w835-h626-no