PDA

View Full Version : Missing Table Saw Guards



CPeter James
05-27-2018, 5:57 PM
I am trying to buy a small table saw for my niece. All the saws on CL are missing the guards and the owners do not have them. There must by a large cache of them someplace! This applies to old and new alike. Doesn't anyone ever use theirs? I have an overarm guard on my PM66. The original one was among the missing when I bout it used. It was about 10 years old at the time.
CPeter

Mike Cutler
05-27-2018, 6:06 PM
Mine are in a box in the loft. If I ever CL my table saws, I'm pretty sure I can find all the OEM parts
I know I don't use them. I'm sure they allow the manufacturer to meet some minimum "legal liability" criteria. As far as actually performing a useful function, they're very much lacking.

David Kumm
05-27-2018, 7:53 PM
Buy a good quality saw in good shape, set it up and adjust it- and add a sharkguard from Lee Styron. A saw with a crappy fence that doesn't keep its settings is scary. Dave

John TenEyck
05-27-2018, 8:02 PM
You can often find OE replacement guards from the manufacturer; certainly, you still can for any Sears saw. But the recommendation to buy a Sharkguard is a good one. In any case, you are doing the right thing to make sure your the saw you give to your niece has a splitter and guard on it. If she starts out using one it will be second nature.

John

Ken Fitzgerald
05-27-2018, 8:32 PM
I'm one of the oddballs who has the blade guard mounted on his saw and uses it unless I am doing a non-thru cut which requires me to remove the guard and the splitter that mounts to it.

Jim Becker
05-27-2018, 8:52 PM
CPeter, most older saws used guards that were inconvenient and cumbersome to remove for non-through cuts...so a "large percentage" of folks pretty much didn't use them and lost track of them. The best replacement would likely be some kind of overarm type because as you know...it can stay on the saw pretty much all the time with little interference.

Wayne Lomman
05-27-2018, 8:53 PM
Get one with guards or retrofit good aftermarket ones. Do you really want to present your niece with a machine that is not guarded and live with the consequences. If anyone wants to remove their own guards, that is their choice. Remove it for someone else? Let them make their own choice.

As I have said before, if you can't use your saw with a guard, you need to learn because your training is lacking. Even if you need to remove the standard guard for some tasks, it is not hard to clamp a temporary guard in place for that task. When you are finished, put the proper guard back on. Cheers

Frederick Skelly
05-27-2018, 8:57 PM
My Delta contractor saw came without a guard. I wanted a new, aftermarket guard and finally settled on a Shark Guard. One small step in the right direction...

Osvaldo Cristo
05-27-2018, 9:41 PM
I'm one of the oddballs who has the blade guard mounted on his saw and uses it unless I am doing a non-thru cut which requires me to remove the guard and the splitter that mounts to it.

The same here but I experiment some frustration as I cannot make a non thru cut removing only the guard but maintaining the splitter... unfortunately I have to remove both for a non thru cut.

BTW even my sledge can work with both guard and splitter at their place.

Regards.

Mike Cutler
05-28-2018, 9:23 AM
As I have said before, if you can't use your saw with a guard, you need to learn because your training is lacking. Even if you need to remove the standard guard for some tasks, it is not hard to clamp a temporary guard in place for that task. When you are finished, put the proper guard back on. Cheers

Wayne
I'm not sure what kind of guards come standard, OEM, on saws outside the US. For many of the saws sold here, the OEM blade guard, and splitters, were just awful.
They were really cheap stamped metal that would deform out of shape seemingly on their own. I could never keep mine aligned for any length of time. It was like the vibration of the saw would cause them to move. If you just bumped one, it was sure to be bent.
The actual splitters weren't the same thickness as any normally kerfed blade, effectively doing nothing. The height under the ratcheting pawls precluded using any material over an inch thick, and the springs on those pawls were guaranteed to leave two lines down the face of any material. None of them came OEM with any dust collection capability whatsoever. Many folks took them off as they were just as much a liability, as a benefit, and made their own.
My blade guard/dust hood is based on a design someone on the forum presented here, many years ago. It suspends from the ceiling, and can be swung up and out of the way when not needed.
I made my own splitter out of 1/8" plate steel.

What's interesting is that many of the overhead blade guard/dust collector hood, designs out now are very, very, similar to some of the home built solutions I saw presented on wood working forums 15-20 years ago. I think small fabricators saw an existing market and moved into it. Which was a good thing.

John TenEyck
05-28-2018, 2:56 PM
Mike, not looking for an argument, but thought it worthwhile to point out that the guard on my old CI Sears saw has integrated dust collection, a splitter that is about 0.1" wide, and pawls approx. 3" above the table which don't scratch the wood traveling underneath. I'll admit it wasn't the easiest thing to align or keep aligned, but I always thought that to be a small price to pay for helping keep all my fingers safe in case I did something stupid. My well used Unisaw came, surprise to no one, without a guard. I fabricated my own splitter and repurposed the Sears guard onto an overhead mount. It meets my needs w/o issue.

Using a guard is more about choice than anything else. If you have your mind made up that it's a pain, inconvenient, can't see, whatever, then you won't use one. But if you view it as a seatbelt on a car, something you never need until you do, then you will learn to use one. A year or so ago I badgered one of my woodworking friends into getting a Shark guard. He said he'd never even had a kickback in 35 years of woodworking, but decided maybe a guard would be OK. I asked him a month or so ago how he liked it and he said it didn't bother him at all. Old dogs can change.

John

Wayne Lomman
05-28-2018, 3:28 PM
Following on from Mike's comment, it would appear that Australia is not plagued poor quality guarding. I even have a cheap no-brand Chinese combo machine in the corner that is accurately and conveniently guarded. My advice is if the guard doesn't work, replace it rather than discard it. The seatbelt analogy is a good one. Cheers

Martin Wasner
05-28-2018, 4:15 PM
He said he'd never even had a kickback in 35 years of woodworking,

How is that even possible? Some odd ball operations it's an oddity when something doesn't come winging out of the saw.

Lee Schierer
05-28-2018, 5:11 PM
I am trying to buy a small table saw for my niece.

I would recommend taking a look at the Rigid 4512 13 amp 10" table saw. This saw has all the guards, a cast iron top and a fence that locks down repeatably. My son purchased one in December and I helped him assemble it. The directions have a couple of weak spots, but they will work to get the saw together. It is a belt driven saw. Assembly takes about 2 hours. The saw was very closely aligned out of the box and the small tweaks I made were pretty easy to do. It is a pretty good investment for just over $500 and the guards are easy to work with though it does take a time or two to get used to how they go on and off.386691

John TenEyck
05-28-2018, 8:49 PM
How is that even possible? Some odd ball operations it's an oddity when something doesn't come winging out of the saw.

I have no clue Martin. And this guy has produced a fair amount of work for a hobbiest and is not prone to exaggerate. He uses some nice wood, but still.

He not only had no guard he had no splitter on it either. I cringed every time I looked at it. But I eventually wore him down and he got the Shark guard. And as I said before, he likes it just fine now that he has one.

John

Mike Heidrick
05-30-2018, 7:00 PM
I use mine after i put my thumb in my ss. I was using it with just a rk at the time. I used the rk after kickback with nothing. I am a slow learn i guess.

Simon MacGowen
05-30-2018, 7:09 PM
I use mine after i put my thumb in my ss. I was using it with just a rk at the time. I used the rk after kickback with nothing. I am a slow learn i guess.

Dont think you.re a slow learner. Bad habits die hard is more likely the case. I use a SawStop and a neighbor once came to my shop for a quick cut and asked me how he could remove the blade guard so he could see. He was def old school.

Simon

Tony Pisano
05-31-2018, 6:51 AM
It would be nice to see some photos of shop made guards that work well.

Wade Lippman
05-31-2018, 10:05 AM
I wonder if you would have liability for injuries if you sell a used saw without a guard.

Martin Wasner
05-31-2018, 8:38 PM
I wonder if you would have liability for injuries if you sell a used saw without a guard.

In this day and age, I bet with the right lawyer you could sue Sawstop for not putting their kit on a saw that was made before the company existed.

John TenEyck
05-31-2018, 9:28 PM
It would be nice to see some photos of shop made guards that work well.

Here's what I use on my Unisaw. It's an old Sears TS guard that I added dust collection to and mounted to an overhead, articulated arm. There is a block of wood at the top of the splitter that keeps the guard centered over the blade. Of course, the guard doesn't tilt with the blade, but you can use it when cutting dados. No system is perfect.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-xNkCrseQt6BqF_Pgi3ZVkuP_XMU-dAUZGU35vzphsnvtjXYeZ1AkJl2XFk8eOZDEmatIMMWxKv7tZ1 Osis91XLrRpXGchr-NTAziYEPMtkGVX5AFc9WlXdZia2t8g-ligBRxwg6iik5dtIk8-N7PPokNutzd2gnt7VPY8FDnvM6l_gMzAwTerj-vtGd-a7tWg3YLDECiQzDlAWtLScovQ8aSkpUgU2IAB-gcedeuQjvtjJ1ae_8_UqZLnKVrQ9DrbGgOTCjLSKgmnbKM1rvH uyn6rcxQvnwMCp3yR1jGbTckT2hGnuQksHMpO72igj3KRlA24U 1-MEPRwMbAXRnNacqUxrUyuXxkTjmgV4mp0hmELIbQzLlvnRoIeL rxRVY6ncVqDvDNaTXYE6CF3WzaXrARYapyPeKsjKiq5crZ7UQV gjSSRVhrr1KwwBaZqBRQJvdUIuyen2kqMGCHpMMMRGM_nNhOf0 5Ev5dCxpzIbBni5IJFZyqD-7YOb1LqjTckYF8_xy_b_4YPYO4yDN2rWL4cm4ZE2pWmaLGBW7m cX_nDLo9Uz43LLP5oALGXkiCN36lcfK7kKNT5QfKjRXFrQMyO4 wwZqQv3HQ9SR8=w835-h626-no

John

David Kumm
06-01-2018, 9:57 AM
Take a look at the saw guard made by Harvey. It is an overhead but looks like a decent design. They are priced in the 550-650 range. Dave