PDA

View Full Version : Tearout



ken hatch
11-11-2017, 12:29 AM
I'm in the short rows on the boy child's table. It is ready for glue up in the AM. that and a little oil and the sucker will be out of the shop.


Getting the legs ready for glue up was a PITA because they are Sapele. I don't know if you have worked with Sapele, once finished it is beautiful but it is very difficult to work with hand tools, getting to ready for finishing isn't easy. The problem is it is soft and has stripes of reversing grain which of course leads to tearout even when using the sharpest cutters unless the cap iron is set to control the tearout. With an improper set up plane the tearout can be so deep and severe a scrapper is almost worthless. The best approach is two part, setting the cap iron correctly to control the tearout then follow with light scrapping if needed. Many times just correct setting of the cap iron will be all that is needed. Here is a photo of one of the Sapele legs after using a #5 Jack to shape the leg. I think you can see how deep the tearout is if you click the image to enlarge it.

371407

As has been posted many times on this forum, to control tearout with the cap iron it, the cap iron, needs to be set back just slightly greater than the desired thickness of the shavings. It is pretty damn close to the cutting edge, in other words when set correctly you should just be able to see a very thin reflection of light off the cutter.


Here is a photo of the leg after smoothing with a #4 with the cap iron set to control tearout. A scrapper is on the bench but I do not think it was used. Again click it to big it.

371408

ken

Brian Holcombe
11-11-2017, 10:06 AM
Nice work Ken!

ken hatch
11-11-2017, 10:22 AM
Nice work Ken!

Thanks Brian. As I worked on the legs last night I thought it might be of interest to show the effect of setting the cap iron for tearout control. I'm sure by this time we all know it works but maybe some haven't seen it work.

ken

David Ragan
11-11-2017, 11:14 AM
Great example of the value of a scraper; that LV holder is great, too.

You like your Benchcrafted planing stop? I have one (but cant decide where to put the 2" square hole in my bench).

Phil Mueller
11-11-2017, 12:20 PM
That sapele is everything you say it is. I did one project with it, and it kept getting thinner and thinner to try to remove the tear out :eek:

Your results are impressive. Thanks for the reminder!

ken hatch
11-11-2017, 1:01 PM
Great example of the value of a scraper; that LV holder is great, too.

You like your Benchcrafted planing stop? I have one (but cant decide where to put the 2" square hole in my bench).

David,

At the time of the photo I hadn't used the scraper. The results were from setting the cap iron.

The planing stop is handy, I go back and forth between it and the batten you see on the end of the bench....both work well.

ken

ken hatch
11-11-2017, 1:03 PM
That sapele is everything you say it is. I did one project with it, and it kept getting thinner and thinner to try to remove the tear out :eek:

Your results are impressive. Thanks for the reminder!

Phil,

Thanks.

Now that made me laugh, BTDT.

ken

Metod Alif
11-13-2017, 9:47 AM
Ken,
A nice and clear demonstration of the effectiveness of a chipbreaker. Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Metod

ken hatch
11-13-2017, 5:46 PM
Ken,
A nice and clear demonstration of the effectiveness of a chipbreaker. Thanks for sharing.
Best wishes,
Metod

Metod,

Thanks,

Sapele is a good wood to demonstrate tear out. At least that is the case in my experience ��

ken