PDA

View Full Version : Yew wood any good? Been offered a standing dead yew tree. Never worked with it.



William Fretwell
12-20-2016, 2:32 PM
I take trees down periodically. This one is just over 2.5 feet at the base. It has been dead a while so it's dry and hard.
Sawing it up into planks could be a lot of work and very hard on my chains so I wonder if it's worth it.

Does yew crack a lot when it dries? What is it like to work with, grain, colour etc?

Staves make good bows but usually Pacific yew seems to be used. My interest is in furniture.

Thanks to anyone who has worked with it.

mark kosse
12-20-2016, 2:58 PM
Great for traditional bows. I've never heard of it used any other way but yew is scarce here in tx.

Jim Koepke
12-20-2016, 3:07 PM
Yew ought to give it a try.

Sorry, couldn't resist,

jtk

Chris Hachet
12-20-2016, 3:15 PM
Let us know how it works out.....would love to harvest some wood myself...

Jerry Olexa
12-20-2016, 3:26 PM
Yew never know.....:)

John Vernier
12-20-2016, 5:41 PM
In England yew is used a lot for traditional Windsor chairs, and I think it is found occasionally as a decorative veneer on 17th-18th century cabinetry.

Glen Canaday
12-20-2016, 6:44 PM
Yew is very, very soft even when dry. It can't take an impact for nothin' and will dent if you look at it too hard. It is very elastic though and not easily broken. Since it's a conifer its heartwood is pretty good in compression but its sapwood is fairly good in tension, unlike most others of the type. That's why it's used in traditional English longbows. If the sapwood is too thick though, it can crack and of course the bow becomes a wall decoration.

The best stuff is very tightly grained. It's had a hard life and the growth rings are paper thin. Lawn yew kinda sucks for bows as It's been watered and pampered. Pacific yew is only one breed; we use it here in the states because, well, it can be had.

The worst thing to look out for with regard to other projects than bows is all the bazillion pin knots it can have.

Edit: 2.5 feet across at the base? That's a big mamajama. Never seen one that big, personally. Lots and lots to play with there.

Jim Belair
12-20-2016, 7:21 PM
There are several varieties of yew and some (maybe all) are toxic and can cause sensitivities. Regarding sensitivity think red cedar or cocobolo. Note on this chart of maybe a couple hundred woods there are only a few labelled with skull and cross bones and yew is one of them.

http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/wood-allergies-and-toxicity/

Glen Canaday
12-20-2016, 7:30 PM
There are several varieties of yew and some (maybe all) are toxic and can cause sensitivities. Regarding sensitivity think red cedar or cocobolo. Note on this chart of maybe a couple hundred woods there are only a few labelled with skull and cross bones and yew is one of them.

http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/wood-allergies-and-toxicity/

Apologies, I rarely consider power tool users since I'm not one myself. The above chart is something to consider.

John Vernier
12-20-2016, 7:49 PM
Wow! note that that Wood Database article opens with this quote:

“Not to omit any one of them, the yew is similar to these other trees in general appearance . . . It is an ascertained fact that travellers’ vessels, made in Gaul of this wood, for the purpose of holding wine, have caused the death of those who used them.” –Pliny the Elder, from Naturalis Historia, ca. 77 AD

So, not a great choice for bowls or cups!

george wilson
12-21-2016, 10:17 AM
Post #9 seems VERY strange: Yew is a pretty HARD wood,though it looks like a cedar. It was used to make the long bows which the English used to such great effect in their early wars. They used yew so much that even in medieval times they had to import it from Spain.

Most English yew these days is grown in cemeteries,fenced off so cattle can't graze beneath it.

I LOVE yew wood. It has a VERY high strength to weight ratio. I made some very deep frame marquetry saws from it. Used one of them to saw out the marquetry on the marquetry guitar I have posted here before.

I'd LOVE to get some yew wood to make a bow!!! Or to make any thing else out of.

I know that cattle can be poisoned by eating fallen yew needles. haven't had any health trouble working it,but I haven't had trouble with any wood,though some certainly have. Especially wood like cocobolo.

I would regard that tree you have as a great treasure,and definitely would have it sawn into useful planks. And,don't leave it laying on the ground. I don't know how long it can stand that before starting to spalt,which would be a HUGE SIN!!!!!

William,what state are you in?

Malcolm Schweizer
12-21-2016, 10:51 AM
Yew is excellent for bentwood chairs, and I agree with George- very hard stuff. Ironically, I was just reading up on Yew the other day, and there were many cautions about the toxicity of it. Apparently even the pollen can be irritating. I would be very careful when felling and resawing it.

george wilson
12-21-2016, 11:18 AM
I have heard of 2x4"s,cut in the Pacific North West,having an occasional yew wood 2x4 mixed in the lot. Never been lucky enough to have spotted and bought one though!

Malcolm McLeod
12-21-2016, 11:21 AM
Yew ... used to make the long bows...

I recall a medieval weapons program on one of the big-number cable channels did an episode on the English longbow. The expert said they split the Yew blank for the bow to include both heart wood and sap wood, one for strength and the other for 'spring'. The combination made it powerful enough to penetrate armor, but tough to draw (>80-90lbs if I remember). I would assume that the position, symmetry, and proportion of the respective wood types is very important.

And for our next adventure down trivia lane, I bring you...

William Fretwell
12-21-2016, 11:33 AM
Thanks for the reply. Seems I will have to take it down. I am in South West Ontario.
I had not thought about making tool handles from it. I considered drawer bottoms. I will have to cut 7 feet off the end and split out bow staves for fun. The rest of the trunk can be boards out of the middle then quarter sawn for chair spindles or tool handles.
I know the leaves will kill cattle. This one is on a very large lawn at the top of a creek bank so it may have been spoilt with water.
It has been on his great grandfathers property a very long time.

William Fretwell
12-21-2016, 11:57 AM
That chart is a little irritating :) Chestnut dust causing nasal cancer is well documented but does not even make it on the chart!
Have to wear my good dust mask when I rip the boards. I do have good dust extraction above and below as well as an air cleaner. It still gets all over however.
Wooden spoons, cutting boards and food bowls won't make it on the list. Bows were sealed with oil, to protect the bow not the archer.
Yes hand tools are almost dust free if you don't beat the sandpaper on the bench to clear it!

Jim Koepke
12-21-2016, 12:02 PM
That chart is a little irritating Chestnut dust causing nasal cancer is well documented but does not even make it on the chart!

Elder (Sambucus) is also not on the list. Likely a lot of others that have been omitted.

jtk

Dennis Peacock
12-21-2016, 12:06 PM
I had a friend of mine give me some Yew wood that he cut in Florida. This was several years ago and I made a couple of wooden spatulas out of that Yew wood and even with it being so soft? We are still using those spatulas today....after over 10 years of almost daily use. They have survived repeated dishwasher washings, hand washing in the sink, and left un-oiled for a long time. The LOML says that these are among her most favorite ones to use because they are large enough and weigh so little. I don't know the specific species of Yew....but whatever this was? It has held up extremely well. Oh yea! I even made a couple of nightstands out of the wood and they are in use today and beautiful as ever. And here I thought they would only be temporary until I could make some nicer ones. ;) :)

Nicholas Lawrence
12-21-2016, 2:29 PM
I have never handled Yew, but I have read that there is a big difference in the hardness of the inner rings and the outer rings (which is which I don't remember).

William Fretwell
12-21-2016, 4:26 PM
From what I've read 10 lbs of bow stave is shaved down to 1.5 lbs with draw knives then spoke shaves. It gets bent gradually and often during this process balancing out the two kinds of wood. The bark side (sap wood) is not cut but the bark is removed very carefully. As the 'D' shape is formed the bow is pulled on a form with pulleys and the shape critiqued against a wall. The process can take up to 4 years!

george wilson
12-21-2016, 7:30 PM
I hope it doesn't take 4 years!!!:) It COULD if drying time is included,I suppose. The old English bows drew at 130# pull! It was required by law that all men and boys had to practice archery every day. It was the only way that they could develop the strength to pull such strong bows. The English relied heavily upon the skill of their archers.

By the way: The shooting of arrows into the air and raining them down with deadly effect upon the enemy is pure NONSENSE. Arrows barely stand up when they rain down on the ground after being shot into a high arch in the air. The old tapestries show archers shooting STRAIGHT horizontally at the enemy.

I am a member of the Long Bow Society,and we shoot every Summer here in Williamsburg. I really desire to make myself a yew bow,but not a 130# one!!:)

I have a funny story about shooting into the air: When I was a kid in Alaska,I made my arrows and bent tin can lids into a triangular tip for some of them. This kid wanted to shoot my bow,and he climbed up onto the top of a 6 foot tall stump about 3 feet in diameter. Then he took the bow and shot it straight up. The funny part was when he realized the arrow was coming straight down onto HIM. He yelled "OH NO!!",and clasped his hands over the top of his head. He was stuck up there with no place to go! That arrow came down right between his fingers without even touching them. It bounced straight back up into the air several feet,with a loud "BOINK!"after hitting his skull. It made him bleed,but did not penetrate the skull. I am sure the kid never repeated that stunt.

Frederick Skelly
12-21-2016, 8:12 PM
It was required by law that all men and boys had to practice archery every day. It was the only way that they could develop the strength to pull such strong bows. The English relied heavily upon the skill of their archers.

I have a funny story about shooting into the air: When I was a kid in Alaska,I made my arrows and bent tin can lids into a triangular tip for some of them. This kid wanted to shoot my bow,and he climbed up onto the top of a 6 foot tall stump about 3 feet in diameter. Then he took the bow and shot it straight up. The funny part was when he realized the arrow was coming straight down onto HIM. He yelled "OH NO!!",and clasped his hands over the top of his head. He was stuck up there with no place to go! That arrow came down right between his fingers without even touching them. It bounced straight back up into the air several feet,with a loud "BOINK!"after hitting his skull. It made him bleed,but did not penetrate the skull. I am sure the kid never repeated that stunt.

Great story George!

IIRC, the advent of the longbow was the beginning of the end for knights in shining armor. The first time they set those longbow-armed archers on the french, they decimated them because the arrows could penetrate armor. But the nobles found out this was both a good thing (win wars) and a bad thing (English knights were no longer invincible against the lower classes, which supplied the Archers). :)

Jim Koepke
12-21-2016, 8:26 PM
There seems to be quite a few misunderstandings or errant folklore about long bow use.

One is an archer doesn't point the arrow skyward while drawing back. I have seen a few people trying to shot an arrow trying this before someone sets them straight.

Another that I have seen is many archers would have more than a single arrow in their hand when shooting. This allowed a quicker succession of firing arrows than pulling them out of their quiver one by one. Some old tapestries and artwork indicate this practice.

jtk

george wilson
12-21-2016, 10:49 PM
When archers sere captured,they would cut off the fingers that pulled the string back,ensuring that these archers would no longer be used in war. Or anything else involving archery. I think it would have been a bad idea to get into a fight with one in a pub!!!

Glen Canaday
12-23-2016, 5:58 PM
The heartwood is harder than the sapwood. The sapwood you can dent by looking at it with a piercing expression on your face! To clarify for another reply, no, the sapwood isn't cut, true. It is reduced with a dull drawknife to split rings along the pith between them so that the back isn't violated, but still isn't half the bow thick.

Very high strength to weight ratio yes. I should have put it that way. I put it vaguely in terms of elasticity. Ya ain't breaking it, and you're not crushing that heartwood. That's why the English bow can get away with a rounded belly. White woods need a straight belly to distribute the crushing force but yew, osage, and lemonwood can take it concentrated in one spot.

George, regarding the cut off fi gers of the archer - I have come to the understanding that that is where we get the infamous middle finger gesture from! To display to the French that we're still able to shoot ;) Whether that's true or not I'm not worried about, but it sounds like a pretty good story to me!

steven c newman
12-23-2016, 6:53 PM
In England, it is the index and social finger of the right hand that is held
aloft for all to see. At a Horse show other there, the rider was a bit put out by the score the judges gave him, and flipped them off in a "salute"....

The "V" for Victory sign? Same thing, Winston was just flipping off Adolph.....

Jim Koepke
12-23-2016, 9:05 PM
George, regarding the cut off fi gers of the archer - I have come to the understanding that that is where we get the infamous middle finger gesture from! To display to the French that we're still able to shoot ;) Whether that's true or not I'm not worried about, but it sounds like a pretty good story to me!

As Tom & Ray, the tappet brothers, proclaimed we also get an expression from the battle of Agincourt about the process of shooting an arrow being referred to as "plucking yew" being transformed into today's all to common expletive. It would be a two for one, if true.

Serious historians might not agree:


(King) Henry made a speech emphasising the justness of his cause, and reminding his army of previous great defeats the kings of England had inflicted on the French. The Burgundian sources have him concluding the speech by telling his men that the French had boasted that they would cut off two fingers from the right hand of every archer, so that he could never draw a longbow again. Whether this was true is open to question; as previously noted, death was the normal fate of any soldier who could not be ransomed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Agincourt

It is still a good story.

jtk

Glen Canaday
12-25-2016, 6:59 AM
I agree. Let's go with it. Maybe I should change the f word in my spell checker to "pluck," for dubious historical purposes ;)

Bohdan Pasemko
01-17-2022, 6:18 PM
Yew is very, very soft even when dry. It can't take an impact for nothin' and will dent if you look at it too hard. It is very elastic though and not easily broken. Since it's a conifer its heartwood is pretty good in compression but its sapwood is fairly good in tension, unlike most others of the type. That's why it's used in traditional English longbows. If the sapwood is too thick though, it can crack and of course the bow becomes a wall decoration.

The best stuff is very tightly grained. It's had a hard life and the growth rings are paper thin. Lawn yew kinda sucks for bows as It's been watered and pampered. Pacific yew is only one breed; we use it here in the states because, well, it can be had.

The worst thing to look out for with regard to other projects than bows is all the bazillion pin knots it can have.

Edit: 2.5 feet across at the base? That's a big mamajama. Never seen one that big, personally. Lots and lots to play with there.

You've got to be kidding!
I've been using the same yew-wood carving mallet for over 10 years and hardly shows a dent or bruise.
Made from well-seasoned (1 year/inch of thickness) cut live in the bush here.

Scott Winners
01-18-2022, 3:15 AM
If you want to bow hunt Alaska trophy moose this year, you need a bow with a 55# pull. 80-130# is, err, not unreasonable if you are going up against plate armour I guess. I know nothing about yew specifically, though a quick internet search says good firewood, but do not cook with it. Cutting 7 feet off the stump to make bow staves is potentially lucrative, for the rest I got nothing.

Jim Tobias
01-18-2022, 11:11 AM
My only experience with Yew has been Yew Burl veneer. If there are any crotches/burls or figured areas, I would guess it could produce some gorgeous veneers.
The attached is a table I did many years back using Yew Burl veneer.

Jim
471857

Dave Zellers
01-18-2022, 2:48 PM
The attached is a table I did many years back using Yew Burl veneer.

That table is stunning! :eek: Gorgeous beyond words.

Jim Tobias
01-18-2022, 3:00 PM
Thanks Dave. I was alwaysblown away by the beauty of that Yew Burl Veneer.....just beautiful wood!!

Adam Herman
01-18-2022, 4:27 PM
its frowned upon around here as an ornamental as it will kill the Elk and Mule Deer.