PDA

View Full Version : Buying blades for a new Sawstop 3hp. Please double check me…



Kyle Mills
06-25-2015, 4:39 PM
I’m going from an underpowered saw that I use with thin kerf blades to a Sawstop that I want to use full kerfs on. Historically, I’ve had two blades—a glue line rip blade and a crosscut blade that I could use on pretty much everything including melamine and veneered plywood.

I like to have blades that are the exact same kerf so that my tape always measures the same and this seems to go double for the Sawstop due to potential brake spacing issues. Also, you can’t have depth-limiting shoulders or coated blades because they can interfere with the safety feature.

The only blades I can find that fit the bill are from Carbide Processors. The glue line rip blade (http://www.carbideprocessors.com/worlds-best-37208-gang-rip-and-straightline-rip-saw-blades/) and the melamine veneer blade (http://www.carbideprocessors.com/worlds-best-50601-melamine-veneer-saw-blades/).

Do you see any problems with using these blades? Is there a better—and perhaps cheaper—option that you know of? Any thoughts would be helpful.

Thanks!

John Schweikert
06-25-2015, 4:52 PM
I use Forrest, Carbide Processors, Oshlun, Tenryu, Freud red coated and clear coated with my PCS. No issues with any of them. Plenty of blades with true 1/8" kerfs from many manufacturers. You may be over thinking this or unnecessarily worrying.

Chris Padilla
06-25-2015, 5:06 PM
I use 3 types of blades:

(1) crosscut (very high tooth count, alternating top bevel (ATB))
(2) ripping (very low tooth count, flat top)
(3) general purpose (tooth count in the 40-50 arena, usually ATB)

From this group, you'll have your 'good' blades for nice hardwoods/plywoods and your 'crappy' blades for junky plywood, MDF, and other stuff you don't want to use your 'good' blades on. You'll probably have at least 4-6 blades on hand at any one time. Waiting for a blade to be sharpened can be a pain so that is where multiples creep in on ya.

All are 1/8" kerf...very standard...everyone makes 'em. :)

scott spencer
06-25-2015, 6:54 PM
I hear nothing but good things about World's Best blades, but both are a tad steep IMO. I definitely wouldn't spend close to $80 for a 24T rip blade. You'll have a very hard time differentiating between the performance of good 24 tooth rip blades, so I don't see good reason to pay a premium for that one. They're generally considered a rougher cutting very efficient blade suitable for thick rips...the best of them are marginally capable of a glue line cut if all goes well (there are several factors involved). I'd also prefer a flat top grind (FTG) to the TCG. There are several really good 24T full kerf FTG rip blades for $50-$60....Freud LM72, Infinity 010-024, CMT 201.024.10, Guhdo 2400.100A24, Amana Tools, etc. I'd even consider a $30 Oshlun for this type of bull work.

There are also several excellent choices in a melamine veneer blade ($100+ buys an awesome blade), but it's worth determining what your volume levels will be first. High volume commercial shops favor edge life at the expense of some cut quality. If your volumes are that of a typical hobbyist, you can get the best cut performance without worrying much about edge life. If that's the case, I'd look to a Hi-ATB grind like the Freud LU80, Infinity 010-080 Ultrasmooth, CMT 210.080.10, Forrest Duraline, or Amana MB10800.

I'd also look to get some sort of a 40T to 50T all purpose blade too. The Delta 35-7657 (http://www.amazon.com/35-7657-10-Inch-General-Purpose-Circular/dp/B000O7UESC/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1435272892&sr=8-1&keywords=delta+35-7657) is tough to beat at a clearance price of ~ $30 shipped. US made, 40T ATB, full kerf, C4 carbide, well made blade that'll give many $100 blades a run for their money.

Kyle Mills
06-25-2015, 7:26 PM
There are several really good 24T full kerf FTG rip blades for $50-$60....Freud LM72, Infinity 010-024, CMT 201.024.10, Guhdo 2400.100A24, Amana Tools, etc. I'd even consider a $30 Oshlun for this type of bull work.

I'd never heard of Guhdo. Seems like a great price and it's .126. The others aren't appropriate because of the shoulders that are strictly forbidden by Sawstop.


There are also several excellent choices in a melamine veneer blade ($100+ buys an awesome blade), but it's worth determining what your volume levels will be first. High volume commercial shops favor edge life at the expense of some cut quality. If your volumes are that of a typical hobbyist, you can get the best cut performance without worrying much about edge life. If that's the case, I'd look to a Hi-ATB grind like the Freud LU80, Infinity 010-080 Ultrasmooth, CMT 210.080.10, Forrest Duraline, or Amana MB10800.

I actually have the thin kerf version of the LU80 and really like it. And this one is .126 like the Guhdo.


I'd also look to get some sort of a 40T to 50T all purpose blade too. The Delta 35-7657 (http://www.amazon.com/35-7657-10-Inch-General-Purpose-Circular/dp/B000O7UESC/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1435272892&sr=8-1&keywords=delta+35-7657) is tough to beat at a clearance price of ~ $30 shipped. US made, 40T ATB, full kerf, C4 carbide, well made blade that'll give many $100 blades a run for their money.

Great price but unfortunately .118 kerf. I really would like them to all be equal this time around. I've made more than a few mistakes forgetting about the differences in my blades. :mad:

glenn bradley
06-25-2015, 8:02 PM
I’m going from an underpowered saw that I use with thin kerf blades to a Sawstop that I want to use full kerfs on. Historically, I’ve had two blades—a glue line rip blade and a crosscut blade that I could use on pretty much everything including melamine and veneered plywood.

I like to have blades that are the exact same kerf so that my tape always measures the same and this seems to go double for the Sawstop due to potential brake spacing issues. Also, you can’t have depth-limiting shoulders or coated blades because they can interfere with the safety feature.

The only blades I can find that fit the bill are from Carbide Processors. The glue line rip blade (http://www.carbideprocessors.com/worlds-best-37208-gang-rip-and-straightline-rip-saw-blades/) and the melamine veneer blade (http://www.carbideprocessors.com/worlds-best-50601-melamine-veneer-saw-blades/).

Do you see any problems with using these blades? Is there a better—and perhaps cheaper—option that you know of? Any thoughts would be helpful.

Thanks!

I made the switch to Carbide Processors awhile back. I can get just the blade I am after and have, over time, replaced my whole arsenal. I use a 30T rip, a 50T combo, a 50T FTG that is for specific slots that I use on some pieces, a 55T plywood blade, a 60T and an 80T. I have them all ground to 1/8" kerf which reduces the carbide a bit so, decide on that for yourself. This is my choice as I have quite a range of jigs, sleds and fixtures and its nice to be able to use them interchangeably without issue. This may not be important to others and I get that.

I have had some of the stable resharpened although you wouldn't know it to look at them. I have used many top name brands and many of them are quite good and worth the money. After having used the Carbide Processor products for some time I just automatically call on them when in need. The lifetime on the blades is what makes them a bargain to me. I keep track of such things and am at a nearly 3 to 1 ratio on the WWII sharpening schedule and over a 3 to 1 ratio on the Freuds.

P.s. I run a SS 3HP PCS and change the blades without the need to adjust the brake. This is not really any big deal and I adjusted the brake for blade changes for quite awhile as I rotated the other makers blades out of stock. It never did me any harm ;-) My point is that this is not a decision-maker or a deal-breaker as far as I'm concerned; just a nice bonus.

John Schweikert
06-25-2015, 11:52 PM
I went through the Sawstop manual and nowhere do they "forbid" a blade with shoulders.

Exact quote from the manual:

"Blades with depth-limiting shoulders may take longer to stop in the event of an accident than standard blades, and you could receive a more serious injury. Therefore, SawStop recommends using blades without depth-limiting shoulders."

"recommends ... without" and "forbid" are worlds apart.

Kyle Mills
06-26-2015, 11:56 AM
I went through the Sawstop manual and nowhere do they "forbid" a blade with shoulders.

Exact quote from the manual:

"Blades with depth-limiting shoulders may take longer to stop in the event of an accident than standard blades, and you could receive a more serious injury. Therefore, SawStop recommends using blades without depth-limiting shoulders."

"recommends ... without" and "forbid" are worlds apart.

Yeah, but they write it in bold!

Since I have to buy new blades anyway, I figure why buy one that could reduce the effectiveness of the saw's safety features? Particularly, when the recommended ones are just as good and no more expensive.

Steve Wilde
06-26-2015, 3:08 PM
I put a Forrest 40 tooth ww2 blade on my 3 hp pcs. I can't complain whatsoever about the blade. I'm looking for a ripping blade as we'll and won't estimate to buy another Forrest.

Kyle Iwamoto
06-26-2015, 7:22 PM
The brake is capable of stopping a whole dado stack, and that's pretty heavy. Should stop a shouldered blade too.
I run Forrest WWII, Freud Glueline rip, cheapo 10 buck HD combo blade for recycled wood, Freud bulk ripper, Avantis. All the blades seem to run fine, no problems with paint, teflon etc. They all run perfectly fine on my ICS.

Chris Padilla
06-26-2015, 7:37 PM
I wondered why a depth of cut limiting blade would be harder to stop unless it is just the extra bit of rotational mass beyond the ~5" radius?

While they can stop a much more massive dado blade, I bet that brake is stronger than the brake for a regular, single saw blade. I'm just guessing.

Larry Frank
06-26-2015, 7:57 PM
If I had some good thin kerf blades, I would use them. I have the Sawstop PCS and use a mix of the thin kerf and full kerf blades. No reason to toss a good blade.

Mike Heidrick
06-26-2015, 9:28 PM
Adjusting for dia of blade takes seconds. I would not sweat that.

joe milana
06-26-2015, 10:15 PM
I believe that a depth limiting blade takes longer to imbed itself in the aluminum brake and come to a complete stop due to the "depth limiting" feature.

As far as blades, my favorite, and I have a whole collection of blades, is the Freud premier fusion 40T High atb. It just seems to give me the best result. In fact, I just took one off tonight to send to the sharpener, and replaced it with a WWII. The WW just has a wierd feel to it while cutting, and makes some odd harmonic sounds. It's almost brand new too. :confused:

Kent A Bathurst
06-27-2015, 3:52 AM
I put a Forrest 40 tooth ww2 blade on my 3 hp pcs. I can't complain whatsoever about the blade. I'm looking for a ripping blade as we'll and won't estimate to buy another Forrest.


I assume spellcheck took you to estimate, rather than hesitate, in which case......

I have a bunch of Forrest - all std kerf. Observations for you, in case you are interested......

The WW II works fine for ripping most wood.

However - I have a 30t and a 20t rip blade for [roughly] 6/4 and 8/4, respectively. They work great - very easy cuts, even in hard domestic stuff, like QSWO.

I also have the 80t Hi-AT blade for panels, and also for crosscuts where I want to be particularly picky.

Btu - the WW II does 80%+ of the work. To the point that I have 2, so there is a sharp one on the saw, and the other is out to be sharpened.

If you don't cut a lot of the very thick stuff, you can get great results with just the 40t WW II. I do a lot of my work in 4/4-5/4.... So - mabye you don't need a dedicated rip for blade #2 - maybe the Hi-AT?

Just laying out your options...........

Oh - and I have the dado king, and 2 x 12" 80t chopmaster.

I also have a 10" 80t chopmaster from previous CMS - gave the saw away to a friend, but he did not want to drop $100 on a blade. I have been known to run that on the TS for crosscuts as well...........

David Ragan
06-27-2015, 4:36 AM
I will come in as the simpleton.

Have had all kinds of cheaper BORG blades years ago.

Then, after some research, just got a bunch of Forrest WWII. For what I do, they are fine with my SS.

I don't count of a TS cut to be to finish cut. Perhaps one of the many things I am doing incorrectly....

David Kuzdrall
06-27-2015, 7:44 AM
I have three Freud blades and they are three different kerf thinknesses; very annoying when they mount on the fence side of the arbor as the scale is only accurate for one of them. Yes...it is a small difference but if you switch blades mid project then it can cause some trouble for precise work.

when I am doing something critical, I use the fusion combo 40-tooth blade and don't change it out to ensure consistent cuts.

glenn bradley
06-27-2015, 8:24 AM
I have three Freud blades and they are three different kerf thinknesses; very annoying when they mount on the fence side of the arbor as the scale is only accurate for one of them. Yes...it is a small difference but if you switch blades mid project then it can cause some trouble for precise work.

when I am doing something critical, I use the fusion combo 40-tooth blade and don't change it out to ensure consistent cuts.

Good observation. This is another reason that I have CP make my cutters 1/8" kerf. You could pick any width within reason but, 1/8" suits me.

Just for clarity on my previous post, I do have a collection of quality TK blades left over from my hybrid saw. I use them still now and again. If you have quality cutters, I would use them. If they are questionable, I would replace with blades that meet your needs.

Keith Hankins
06-27-2015, 9:17 AM
Well first off, Congratulations you will love the new saw. I've had mine for about 1.5 years now, and absolutely love my ICS. I too went from thin kerf to full kerf. I started by using the regular blade that came with the saw, and even bought their professional blade. The cut of the stock blade ok but not for fine finish cuts that I'm use to with my Forrest blades. I put that one away for emergency cuts. Again, it's an ok blade.

My 2nd blade I tried was the Titanium blade they recommended. I have to admit for the money it's a good blade. Plenty of Carbide and the cuts are good on the cross cuts. Obviously rips will be great, and are clean. At 69$ a great value.

I also tried my Forrest 20T rib blade in my saw. I have that for ripping 12/4 and 16/4 stock. I notice my first issue with the fact that not all blades are exactly 10". I had to adjust my brake space a hair as it was small, but enough to trip the warning light on the console and prevent starting. I twas a quick turn of the supplied wrench and it was resolved. I will suggest you put a couple rare earth magnets on the edge of your saw and keep your wrench and splitter for quick access. Another tip is, I took a sharpie and put a mark on the brake spacer nut and saw to mark spot for that blade. If you switch between blades it makes any adjustment a few seconds.

When I sold my Griz 1023slx I kept my thin kerf blades and sold all 3 of them and took that money to pay for Forrest WWII 40T blade and the 20T rip blade. I had a full kerf WWI which is a good crosscut blade that I had on my RAS.

Of all my blades, the Forrest is top line. I have to say up front, I'm a fan of Forrest blades and have been since I bought my first one years ago! They have a ton of carbide and the cut is perfect.

I've been using those exclusively for almost the full time now. The WWII does great Cross cuts and perfect rips. The only time I've changed blades is when I'm using the rip blade for thick stock.

I'm sure other blades give a good cut, but don't recall ever getting bad reviews on the Forrest blades.

Cheers!

Ruperto Mendiones
06-27-2015, 11:45 AM
I purchased the Carbide Processors glue line rip blade. I am beyond satisfied and I haven't looked back. I think it is worth the $ premium.

John Schweikert
06-27-2015, 4:21 PM
I have a Carbide Processors 37208 rip blade, simply exceptional. Ripped a bunch of 12' lengths of mahogany for gunwales and spray rails.


I purchased the Carbide Processors glue line rip blade. I am beyond satisfied and I haven't looked back. I think it is worth the $ premium.

Steve Wilde
06-27-2015, 11:48 PM
I do quite a bit of work with 8/4 or 10/4 so I am definitely looking to purchase a rip blade. I looked at them today at my local woodcraft, and almost pulled the trigger. I also use a lot of cherry, so I'm assuming a rip blade would help me prevent burning as well. I used my dado king for the first time today, I have to say I was impressed! I'd also like a chopmaster to add to my kapex, but the stock blade is pretty good so that will have to wait, too many other big ticket items to get first.

Kent A Bathurst
06-28-2015, 1:23 AM
I do quite a bit of work with 8/4 or 10/4 so I am definitely looking to purchase a rip blade. I looked at them today at my local woodcraft, and almost pulled the trigger. I also use a lot of cherry, so I'm assuming a rip blade would help me prevent burning as well. I used my dado king for the first time today, I have to say I was impressed! I'd also like a chopmaster to add to my kapex, but the stock blade is pretty good so that will have to wait, too many other big ticket items to get first.


Steve....

You will love a 20t Forrest rip for those big slabs. "help" is the operative word in that sentence. "eliminate" is a bridge too far...2 many variables, but it will happen often....

fewer teeth = rougher cut - need a jointer pass. but - cleaner, and safer - you don't "lean into" the cut - that causes oppo for slips..............i don't care if your saw is hotdog-proof or not - that is smart WW

a 30t is good also...cherry is a "soft" hardwood, imo, compared 2 the HM and especially the QSWO, that i normally run. 30t may be fine 4 cherry, but for my stuff, the 20t is a noticeable improvement over 30t for 8/4 + 10/4

Tom Walz
07-04-2015, 4:14 PM
First, thank you all for the kind remarks.

It is pretty hard tobuy a bad sawblade any more.

There has been a lot of activity in the sawblade industry to improve overallquality. As an example; side clearance deviation on a blade used to runas high as 0.010" and even 0.020". Now it is rarely ashigh as 0.005" on Big Box blades. On the World's Best Bladesit runs 0.0005" or less. (Side Clearance Deviation is a comparisonof the measurement of the tip from the saw plate.)

Basically I spent about 20 twenty years figuring out how to use advancedmaterials for saw blades. We were successful in mills and plants wherecut quality and tool life were extremely important and easy tomeasure. (Nobody knowingly buys a sheet of MDF, etc. with raggededges.)

Then the recession hit and many of my customers (top end saw shops and customblade manufacturers) were suffering. So we started advertising andselling their blades. They bought advanced material saw tips from us, wetold them to make the very best blades they could and then sold thoseblades.