Soliciting design ideas

[Roger Chandler]

I rarely buy wood............most of mine is harvested or given to me. There is the occasional exception however.........as evidenced in this picture.

265663

What I have here is a piece of claro walnut, approx. 6"x6"x4", a piece of yellowheart 6x6x2, and a piece of purpleheart approx. 5x5x3. I have had two pieces for over 2 years and the claro for almost two years........the reason I have not turned anything as of yet with them is that I simply did not know what I wanted to do with them.....what type of form and until I got it straight in my mind, I was not about to take a chance on messing up wood that I paid good money for!

That brings me to my asking for design ideas...........I know that I do not want to make a simple bowl.........perhaps a vessel with lid.......the contrasting colors of either the claro or purpleheart would really show off that yellowheart if it were a lid of some sort.

I am just not sure, so I thought I would take a pic of the blanks and ask for some ideas from the turners here on what you think would be a really good form for these......either two pieces of contrasting wood on a single form or even 3 separate forms......

I want to get a number of ideas, and perhaps if one or two really strike my fancy, then I might name it after the person who suggested it and certainly give them credit for their inspiration here on SMC and a couple of other forums.

Fire away folks! :D

[Curt Fuller]

Sorry I can't be much help Roger. But that's why I never buy much wood either. I can never think of what to do with those size and shaped chunks. I kind of wonder why they always cut them like that. Square edged bowls, plain bowls, shallow hollowforms. The claro piece has the most opportunities.

[Roger Chandler]

Sorry I can't be much help Roger. But that's why I never buy much wood either. I can never think of what to do with those size and shaped chunks. I kind of wonder why they always cut them like that. Square edged bowls, plain bowls, shallow hollowforms. The claro piece has the most opportunities.

Bummer! I would have loved to hear an idea from you........you are right about those "chunks" as they sometimes limit the possibilities!

[Thom Sturgill]

Use claro for the vessel 6" diameter - yellow heart lid as suggested should work. Cut the purpleheart into a 3x3x5 and a 2x3x5 and cut the 2x3x5 into two pieces about 1 1/2x2x5 for finials. Make a goblet or box from the 3x3x5 piece.

[Roger Chandler]

Use claro for the vessel 6" diameter - yellow heart lid as suggested should work. Cut the purpleheart into a 3x3x5 and a 2x3x5 and cut the 2x3x5 into two pieces about 1 1/2x2x5 for finials. Make a goblet or box from the 3x3x5 piece.

Thanks Thom for your input!

[Roger Chandler]

The thought had crossed my mind for a four winged bowl from the claro.......with the wings turned downward and a domed lid with a finial...........

A couple of years ago, or so, John Keeton emailed me a drawing of something similar with the purpleheart, but at the time, I did not know if I could pull off his design.....it was fairly elaborate for my skill level at the time...........I don't think it would be a problem now with the knowledge and tools I have now that I did not possess back then.

Still, I am not sure that is the way I want to utilize the pieces..........so I am certainly open to suggestions.

[robert baccus]

If you haven't try some square bowls and their variations of course. It's a whole new world and skillsets.

[Roger Chandler]

If you haven't try some square bowls and their variations of course. It's a whole new world and skillsets.

Thanks for the suggestion Robert........I appreciate your input. I have done 3 or 4 square bowls............my doctor has one out of walnut, and he mentioned to me last week how much his wife likes it..........they have it prominently displayed in their home.......even though I gave it to him for his office desk.......he said things he cares about are safer at his house than the big office complex!

[Jon Lanier]

I dunno. My way of doing things won't help ya. I make up my mind on a bowl or HF. Then I just start cutting away.... I let the wood 'speak' to me. LOL

I understand the reluctance to use the wood though. My Father-in-Law gave me a piece of Teak, 8"x1.5"x24" about 5 years ago. That stuff is so expensive I just have not had any project jump out at me to say, "Use the Teak!"

[Phil Harris]

For quite a while I have wanted to make a lidded curved wing bowl/box, with the wings curved down for the feet and also wings curved up on the lid. The lid and wings would be proportionally smaller. Then I would remove one of the bowl's wings, and then remove three of the lids wings. The remaining wing on the lid would be lined up where the wing is missing on the bowl. I will make sure when I choose which wings to remove. that I maintain the grain matching like with a box. The lid will be a loose fit so the lid's wing can be used as a handle to raise the lid. I thought of this when I looked at some the winged bowls of Terry something from New Zealand, I'm sorry I cant remember his name right now, he is a terrific artist. I have been holding off trying this till I have better equipment and better skills, I now have adequate equipment so I will soon be trying to develops the skills with some lessor wood until I am ready to try my 80.00 dollar chunk of walnut burl.

Phil Harris

[charlie knighton]

Roger, take a visit to Natural Bridge, see if you get any inspiration there, you might expand your form from that experience

[Roger Chandler]

Roger, take a visit to Natural Bridge, see if you get any inspiration there, you might expand your form from that experience

Its been a few years since I have been to Natural Bridge.......the boys were still in school.....has to have been 17 or 18 years ago...........drive by it fairly often on my way to Roanoke. Are you referring to the natural arch in the bridge itself, or some other feature there?

[Prashun Patel]

This is only my opinion: I find purpleheart hard (no pun intended) to take in big doses. I find it most appealing on smaller items like pens or handles. If it were me, I'd make that blank into small pen or knife handle blanks. It's density makes it also appropriate (IMHO) for a striking mallet head.

Each one of these woods is striking in their own right. My bias is not to mix them.

[John Altberg]

Here is an idea for the walnut and yellow heart. Could even combine with Prashun's idea of using the purple heart for a knob for the lid.

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=224544&d=1329786088

[charlie knighton]

frrom the drive down to natural bridge, anything along the way that catches your eye, the area around natural bridge, natural bridge itself, you might take a camera, be sure to look at the clouds

[Roger Chandler]

Here is an idea for the walnut and yellow heart. Could even combine with Prashun's idea of using the purple heart for a knob for the lid.

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=224544&d=1329786088

I like that John........thanks for digging that one up to look at!

[Roger Chandler]

This is only my opinion: I find purpleheart hard (no pun intended) to take in big doses. I find it most appealing on smaller items like pens or handles. If it were me, I'd make that blank into small pen or knife handle blanks. It's density makes it also appropriate (IMHO) for a striking mallet head.

Each one of these woods is striking in their own right. My bias is not to mix them.

Thanks Prashun........I am not into making knives, although I do have a bit of affinity for them as I am a hunter and they are necessary for processing game..........I do appreciate a quality knife, and I have seen kits available at WoodCraft and other places.

[Roger Chandler]

These posts are getting quite interesting.........I appreciate each and every one of them! Hope more folks will chime in! :)

[John Keeton]

Here is an idea for the walnut and yellow heart. Could even combine with Prashun's idea of using the purple heart for a knob for the lid.

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=224544&d=1329786088Over time, walnut will turn to more of an amber. Claro does this to a lesser degree, but it is still somewhat perceptible. IMO, the addition of the purple heart with the other two would not do well. I like John's suggestion, but I would salvage a corner of the claro to use for a knob.

[robert baccus]

If you do curve down the tips to make feet, you create a real finger abuser. Might try that on a softer wood for practice first for practice. Ouch!

[Eric Gourieux]

265744265745265746265747265748
I haven't made many lidded forms, but I use a lot of similar size blanks. You could make a variation of one of these and make a lid or knob or finial to fit.

[Rick Markham]

The Claro needs to be a vessel!

[Roger Chandler]

265744265745265746265747265748
I haven't made many lidded forms, but I use a lot of similar size blanks. You could make a variation of one of these and make a lid or knob or finial to fit.

Those are all beauties, Eric! I am drawn to the first one and the last one.......of course, I would change the upturned foot to a different configuration for my vessel.......nice stuff! thank you for sharing these!

[Roger Chandler]

The Claro needs to be a vessel!

what type of vessel, Rick?

[John Keeton]

what type of vessel, Rick?Roger, one might try a Schlumpf style SW form. This is one I did from Claro (after stealing Schlumpf's style!:D) that is about the size of your blank.

[Roger Chandler]

Roger, one might try a Schlumpf style SW form. This is one I did from Claro (after stealing Schlumpf's style!:D) that is about the size of your blank.

WoW! That's a looker for sure John! I am sort of leaning towards the idea you sent me a couple years back with a turned down cornered bowl/form with a lid and finial..........just need to settle in my mind about how I want it to look. I can't find that sketch you sent me.........although I have looked in my email archives and in my notebook where I keep design ideas.........I don't know what happened to it, but I remember some of it [vaguely] just not the shape of the top or the finial style.

Do you suppose you kept it in your archives? :D:o

[John Keeton]

Roger, I looked everywhere in my computer files and can't find anything. Sorry!

[Roger Chandler]

Roger, I looked everywhere in my computer files and can't find anything. Sorry!

No problem John...........I really did not mean to trouble you with all that searching.......I thought perhaps you might have remembered it and saved it ........I remember the bottom shape, but not the top so much............not an issue, as I think I can do something that will at least look pretty nice and somewhat similar, and not exact.

You know all those sketches from an artistic mind that you do...........not sure I can replicate that, but it does not have to be your design so much as mine.........I was just looking to do something a little more "high end" than a bowl.........and your sketch came to mind, then I couldn't find it! :(:o