PDA

View Full Version : New chuck?



Ken Hill
09-30-2010, 6:21 PM
I have the new lathe on the way (Delta 46-460) and i am pretty set on getting a better/new chuck over the one I have. Can't say money is no object but I will spend what i have to.

A friend recommended the Baracuda thats on sale at PSI...any input or suggestions?

Many thanks, I know yall will love spending my money!

Thom Sturgill
09-30-2010, 6:29 PM
I have the PSI (2) upgraded to a Nova G3 while I was using the Jet 1220 and now have three Nova SN2s. I feel the Novas are a considerably better chuck, or at least have better jaws, The delta has reversing and the PSI does not have the grub screw to make that safe. Rockler has the Delta model for $164 right now and Amazon lists the G3 w/ 1"-8tpi insert for $145. The Delta model looks like it has different jaws.
Several on here will point to the Grizzly chucks at $100 and others the OneWay - its all what you are used to, Of course VicMarc is the Cadillac.

Richard Madden
09-30-2010, 6:59 PM
Look on Ebay, Nova G3 with insert for $115.00. Free shipping. Also comes with 50mm jaws.

Kyle Iwamoto
09-30-2010, 8:21 PM
+1 on the G3 from the bay. I got mine from there. Supernovas are bigger, but I would think that the G3 is plenty big for the midi. I have a SN 2 also. Good chuck too. Heavy though.

What chuck do you have now?

Allen Neighbors
09-30-2010, 8:25 PM
Look on Ebay, Nova G3 with insert for $115.00. Free shipping. Also comes with 50mm jaws.
And all the Nova jaws will fit it, except for the Titan Powergrips!!:D

Ken Hill
09-30-2010, 8:47 PM
What chuck do you have now?

I dont even recall the brand, woodcrafters had it on sale when I got the lathe.

The Delta G3 looks to be the one I should get due to the reverse ability...?

David E Keller
09-30-2010, 8:55 PM
I've got a Oneway talon and a grizzly chuck. I like both of them, but I greatly prefer the dovetail jaws on the grizzly to the talon jaws that came with the chuck. I seem to have better luck with dovetail tenons than straight tenons.

Jake Helmboldt
09-30-2010, 9:04 PM
I've got a Oneway talon and a grizzly chuck. I like both of them, but I greatly prefer the dovetail jaws on the grizzly to the talon jaws that came with the chuck. I seem to have better luck with dovetail tenons than straight tenons.

Ditto what David said. I have a Barracuda and a ONeway Talon. The PSI quality is actually quite good, but it requires a separate adapter if you ever move up to larger than 1" spindle. I really don't care for the Oneway profiled jaws; I think they are overrated, but some love them. They tend to crush the wood fibers and don't actually hold as well as traditional jaws (IMHO). They easily damage the tenon and make re-chucking difficult. On the plus side, they are made in Canada, not China like so many other chucks/tools. Future jaws will be dovetailed.

John Keeton
09-30-2010, 9:10 PM
Ken, I have three G3 chucks - great little chuck and all you need for the Delta lathe!

James Combs
09-30-2010, 9:28 PM
Ken, here is another vote for the Nova G3 and Nova SN2. I have them both and they serve me well as far as I am concerned.

Jon McElwain
09-30-2010, 10:12 PM
I've got the Nova G3, a nova midi, a Oneway talon, and a stronghold chuck. For a lathe your size I would go with the G3. Good holding power, a range of jaws, chuck key (as opposed to lever bars), and great value. I like to use the talon chuck on my 46-460, but mostly because I have the widest range of accessory jaws for it. That said, I don't think you will be at all disappointed with the G3, and unless you go to a significantly larger lathe and turn larger pieces than your current lathe can hold , the G3 will serve your needs for a long time. Oh, and did I mention that it is about half the cost of the Talon or Vicmarc VM100 chucks? You could buy two jaws (it's really nice to have more than one) for the same price. Yep, I think I've talked myself into another G3.:D

Ken Hill
09-30-2010, 10:16 PM
I'm not the brightest bulb in the bunch, but I see 2 different G3 chucks...one is the Delta G3 designed for the reverse feature on the 46-460. That is the one I should be honing in on correct?

I havent yet been sucked into the bowl turning vortex, most of my work is done on mandrels, but as you can see the force is invading my thought process:D

Thom Sturgill
09-30-2010, 10:27 PM
All of the Nova chucks have the grub screw so that they can be locked to the spindle for reverse turning. If I understand correctly, the Delta G3 version does not use an adapter, but is threaded for 1"-8tpi. It does appear to also have custom jaws with both dovetail and serrations, but will work with standard jaws if you buy others later. The standard version (which requires a $20 adapter) can easily be changed to work on any lathe if/when you upgrade in the future. Standard jaws are dovetail only. Most of the eBay sales I saw included the adapter.

Ken Hill
09-30-2010, 10:38 PM
Ok, that gets me right! I wanted to make sure what i did buy would work!

Bernie Weishapl
09-30-2010, 11:24 PM
Another vote for G3.

Alan Trout
09-30-2010, 11:44 PM
I have an original Nova, G3, SN2, and a Oneway stronghold. I really like my Nova chucks. Even on a full size lathe I use my G3 much of the time because with the small size I can get around it better and easier than a full size chuck and it is good to 14" or so with proper jaws.

Alan

Bob Wolfe
10-01-2010, 12:02 PM
Lots of talk about the teknatool chucks, so I'll chime in. I also have a G3 and a SN2. The G3 was my first and was fine, but I got tired of changing jaws and decided to add another chuck. Woodcraft had a sale on the SN2 so I scooped one up cheap or I probably would have just bought another G3 off ebay. Both chucks are fine for my purpose. I think the SN2 is better quality though, it just feels smoother and more secure when you tighten it. If you go with one of these chucks, don't skimp on the adapter, pay the extra money for the teknatool adapter to go with it. I've heard that the cheap ones aren't deep enough and will cause problems.

Ken Hill
10-01-2010, 12:56 PM
Ordered the G3 and some goodies, many thanks for the advice!!