HELP D-Handle router choice!

[Mike Mastin]

I am torn between the Bosch 2 1/4 HP D-handle router and the Makita 2 1/4 HP D-handle router. Any input would be appreciated by users :confused:

[Charles McKinley]

Hi Mike,

I have the Bosch. It has performed well in my limited use. I like the fine adjustment feature of the Bosch.

[Tom Peterson]

Also own the Bosch. I have the plunge base for it and a mount for my router table. I think that you will be happy with either. I do like the micrometer adjustment feature on the Bosch. Tool reviews put them fairly close. See the other thread on the Amazon discounts both Makita and Bosch offer the $25 off.

[Jerry Ingraham]

I have the Makita and it is a great tool except for the necessity to use two wrenches on the collet. Mine is about 4 years old though so maybe they now have a spindle lock like my 3 1/4 hp Makita has.

[Mark J Bachler]

I have a Porter Cable D handle that I leave set up for dovetails. Motor & switch has held up well, adjustment is easy but again the two wrench thing is a pain in the butt. I also have a Porter Cable plunge router. Love the router, hate the base.

[Steve Jenkins]

Well gee Mike we can't leave you with a choice between the two you listed. Always have to mudddy the waters a bit. Have you looked at the Milwaukee?
It's not a D handle but is designed to be held by the barrel. Has a padded hand grip and strap that goes over your hand. I think its balance feels better than a d handle but maybe that's because I have always held my routers by the barrel rather than the handles.

[Jim Becker]

And I have the D-Handle for my Dewalt 618 and "like it very much". Of course, I think I'm going to like the Festool OF 1400 EQ Plus once it's available...just as comfortable as the D-Handle and it plunges, too.

[Mike Mastin]

The Amazon sale provoked me to do something. I decided on the Makita D-handle as I have always had good luck with their tools and the the Bosch and it were my two favorites. I did not see the Dewalt in person so I did not consider it. I have to be able to touch and hold something to get the feel of it ;)

So like many of you there may be additional routers in my future, but this one will do for now. I have a couple of smaller ones and one larger one for the router table project(now what did I do with that spare time.....)

Happy Holidays to everyone and have a blessed New Year!