View Full Version : Gripping a Hollow Form
Brian Greb
06-10-2010, 1:07 PM
I am about to turn a HF that is 14" tall by 8" in diameter. What is the best size for the tenon and what jaws are best to use?
John Keeton
06-10-2010, 1:24 PM
Brian, I have never done a form that deep, but it would seem to be well within the range of 50mm jaws. I would want the tenon to be just barely larger than the minimum capacity of the jaws so I could have maximum wood/metal contact. As far as length of the tenon, if you have dovetail jaws, going longer than the dovetail portion wouldn't be necessary and probably not a good idea.
But, the real question is - should you use a steady for the form? I would think to hollow something that deep it would be a definite advantage, if not a necessity.
Brian Greb
06-10-2010, 1:30 PM
Brian, I have never done a form that deep, but it would seem to be well within the range of 50mm jaws. I would want the tenon to be just barely larger than the minimum capacity of the jaws so I could have maximum wood/metal contact. As far as length of the tenon, if you have dovetail jaws, going longer than the dovetail portion wouldn't be necessary and probably not a good idea.
But, the real question is - should you use a steady for the form? I would think to hollow something that deep it would be a definite advantage, if not a necessity.
Thanks John,
Would bowl jaws be a better choice due to they have a ribbed gripping surface?
Good point on the steady rest.
I should clarify that I'm going to "cheat" on this one, I'll turn the bottom 9" as a bowl. Then I'll cap the bowl, and hollow the cap.
Allen Neighbors
06-10-2010, 1:40 PM
I would use my 100mm jaws if it wasn't end grain, and my 47mm jaws if it was end grain. I would also use a steady rest.
John Hart
06-10-2010, 1:47 PM
I would use a faceplate and 2" Stainless lag screws.
...but then...that's what I do with most everything.
Steve Schlumpf
06-10-2010, 3:31 PM
I agree with the use of a steady rest but the size jaws depends on how big you plan on leaving that portion of the hollow form. Example - it wouldn't make sense to use a #3 jaws if the finished foot of the HF is going to be 2" or less. Use whatever size jaws you have that comes close - but is still larger - than the finished foot. JMO.
Bernie Weishapl
06-10-2010, 4:29 PM
I use the large jaws for the Vicmarc which is the 4" Dovetail jaws. They grip 3-3/8" to 4-1/4". They hold well.
Mike Peace
06-10-2010, 6:24 PM
Not sure about other chucks but I think you need more than 2" jaws with a SN2.
The Teknatool manual says you should not exceed 6" long and 4" in diameter with a tenon using 50 mm jaws. Using the Powergrip jaws gripping a tenon 3.1" to 4" they saw you can safely grip a piece 12" long and 8" in diameter with a tenon.
Brian Greb
06-10-2010, 6:37 PM
sounds like I need to go buy some new jaws and a stedy.
Steve Mellott
06-10-2010, 6:38 PM
Brian:
I have a followup question to your comment:
I should clarify that I'm going to "cheat" on this one, I'll turn the bottom 9" as a bowl. Then I'll cap the bowl, and hollow the cap.
Why don't you hollow both the bottom and the top separately and then glue them together? I've seen this done as a demo and it turned out (no pun intended) very well.
Steve
Brian Greb
06-10-2010, 6:40 PM
Brian:
I have a followup question to your comment:
I should clarify that I'm going to "cheat" on this one, I'll turn the bottom 9" as a bowl. Then I'll cap the bowl, and hollow the cap.
Why don't you hollow both the bottom and the top separately and then glue them together? I've seen this done as a demo and it turned out (no pun intended) very well.
Steve
I may do that I just want to make sure that the transition is nice and smooth.
Dennis Ford
06-10-2010, 7:42 PM
+ 1 on the face-plate method, I have done a couple that were slightly larger using a face-plate and 1-1/2" lag bolts. (There were 12 1/4" x 1-1/2" lag bolts involved)
Joe Meirhaeghe
06-10-2010, 8:25 PM
I use the standard 2 1/2" jaws on the Vicmarc 5 1/2" chuck or One Way Strong hold chuck on most pieces. ( I use both chucks)
I've used them to turn vessels from 3" tall X 2" dia. all the way up to 480 lb logs that are up to 24" dia. X 36" long.
I make most my dovetailed tenons about 2 1/2" to 2 3/4" dia. X about 3/8" long, even on the 400 plus lb. logs.
I good Steady rest is a MUST though to support the work piece.
The main purpose of the tenon is to drive the piece NOT to Support it. That's what the steady rest is for.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.