PDA

View Full Version : Review of New CSUSA Pen Kit w/PICS



Scott Greaves
04-01-2003, 3:09 PM
A week or so ago I was down to Craft Supplies (The Woodturners Catalog) in Provo Utah. I was there visiting Rex Burningham and Ben Williams, who I met through the Yahoo Penturners Group. I noticed something different in the display case, a new pen style I hadn't seen before. A big, beautiful, classy looking pen! I asked them about it, and they just kind of smiled, and said it will come out in their newest catalog in April. They call it the Gentleman's Pen, and they let me talk them out of a couple of the new kits to try out. I have had an interesting time getting this pen to completion, but last night I finally finished the first of these new kits.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp01.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

<B>The Gentleman's Pen</B>

From Craft Supplies USA, this kit is available in either a fountain pen or a rollerball. It comes in either their durable 10K gold plating, or in the Platinum Series finish. The hardware in this kit is all solid and very well made, which we would expect from Craft Supplies.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp02.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

A full size pen blank is needed to make this pen. The drill bits recommended by Craft Supplies are a 9/16" for the top barrel, and a 15/32" for the bottom barrel, which is just a touch larger than the Havana kit. Have a caution though - I found that the 9/16" bit was <I>too small!</I> I have since picked up a 37/64" bit that should take care of the problem. With the hole drilled with the 9/16" I had to take the Dremel to it and remove enough material so the tube would fit in. A 3/4" x 3/4" blank will just barely accommodate this kit.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp03.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

Despite the overall size of this pen, the wood is actually very thin when you get to the final diameter. Dangerously thin. You will want to use a material that has good continuity and density. I used a blank of stabilized cross-cut spalted ash for this pen. If you don't have good glue coverage over the whole brass tube, you stand a good chance of a blow-out.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp04.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

Turning the pen did not present any major problems. No tenon was required, and the barrel profile was pretty straight. Large pens are often some of the simplest to turn, but they also allow less opportunity for customization.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp05.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

The assembly of the kit is pretty straight forward. Printed instructions were not available for this pen when I picked up these kits, but it was not hard to figure out. The one problem I had, and wouldn't have had if I wasn't in a hurry, is that bottom section of the pen goes together kind of backwards! I assumed the narrower part of the pen would be towards the writing tip, and I ended up seeing how easily this pen disassembled as payment for that assumption! The threads on both the body and the cap are a good quality dense plastic that should wear well.

<BR>
<CENTER><IMG SRC="http://myweb.cableone.net/swedg1/gp06.jpg"></CENTER>
<BR>

My overall impression of the pen is that this is a winner! Craft Supplies has given us a pen that looks fantastic, has good heft and balance, and has a commanding presence. If you like to make and sell high-end pens, this is a kit you will want in your arsenal. These pens should be available from Craft Supplies USA by at least mid April. The price on the 10K Gold finish ranges from $7.99 to $13.99, while the Platinum kit is from $14.99 to $18.99 each. This kit sure makes one awesome looking pen!

Scott Greaves

Ken Salisbury
04-02-2003, 8:36 AM
Great review Scott. From you description it looks like a real winner.

Have you sent my sample kit yet? <IMG src="http://www.klsal.com/smiley2.gif">

Brad Hammond
04-02-2003, 11:29 AM
looks like the answer to berea's "el grande"
cya
brad

great pen by the way

Bob Janka
04-02-2003, 1:28 PM
Scott,

Very nice pen!

This reminds me of a question I've had. You recommended that I use Titanium gold where possible. Yet, this pen kit (as are many others from CS USA) are "10K" gold. I know that both are improvements over the 24K gold in basic kits which has been known to wear off under heavy usage. Have you found much difference between the two? Is there any difference between "upgrade 24K" and "10K" gold?

I'm particularly interested in offering pen and accessories from kits which have a high durability. If I stick to Titanium gold, then that eliminates some of the keyring, pendants, light/fan pulls, and other accessories. It also eliminates some of the specialty pens. If "upgrade 24K" or "10K" have enough durability, I want to offer some items made from these kits.

Thanks in advance for the information!

Cheers,
Bob
Turned Pens are Real Fun!

Scott Greaves
04-02-2003, 10:36 PM
Thanks everybody for the nice comments!

Bob - I still recommend the Titanium as the best finish on the kits for durability. But durability can depend on a number of things. A regular 24K plating can be pretty durable if it is thick. Gold is an alloy, and it makes a big difference what other metals are in the mix. Some of the "upgrade" gold finishes are more durable, and possibly thicker. Gold itself is pretty soft, so a 10K gold has more of the "other" metals in the alloy, which usually makes it more durable than 14K, 18k, 24K, whatever. In jewelry, a lot of men's gold rings are the 10K gold for this reason.

I'm not defending Craft Supplies on this issue. There are a number of us on the Penturners Group (Yahoo) who are disappointed that CSUSA continues to put out pen kits in 10K gold when we feel the Titanium is clearly superior. But we are just consumers, fussy ones at that, and are not privy to all the ins-and-outs of their business decisions. They do make good pen kits! And it appears that their "Platinum Series" kits will be very durable. They are plated in Rhodium, which is in the Platinum group of metals, and is actually stronger, rarer and more expensive than regular Platinum. Hope this helps.

Ken - Since I know you like to get pen kits by the hundred, I'm sending a hundred of them!!! :p (April Fools a day late!)

Scott.

Howard Norman
04-02-2003, 11:05 PM
Scott, as you are probable aware, 24K gold is 100% gold. In the case of the alloys the number giving is the amount of gold. The other carets are other metals. ie. 10K gold is 10/24 gold and 14/24 other metals, or expressed as a percentage 10K gold is 42% gold and 58% other metals

You are correct ithat a lot of mens jewelry is made using 10K gold. High quality jewelry is made from 18K gold.

Howard

Howard Norman
04-02-2003, 11:07 PM
Scott, as you are probable aware, 24K gold is 100% gold. In the case of the alloys the number giving is the amount of gold. The other carets are other metals. ie. 10K gold is 10/24 gold and 14/24 other metals, or expressed as a percentage 10K gold is 42% gold and 58% other metals

You are correct in a lot of mens jewelry being made from 10K gold. High quality jewelry is made from 18K gold.

Howard
[check message length]