Portable Air Compressors....what's your flavor?

[Jim Kirkpatrick]

Looks like my trusty Emglo compressor is on it's last legs. It can no longer maintain anything over 90 lbs. It happened 2 yrs ago and I replaced the rings which worked for a while. I think I paid just under $300 for it and that was over 15 years ago. I went to my local BORG and was surprised to see new compressors for $275....that come with 3 guns!
Anyhoo, looks like the new trend is leaning towards oil-less. I always remember they being noisy.
So what do you have and what are your recommendations? I primarily use it in the shop but still want it to be portable for other projects so I don't want a stationary but I dunno. For some instances a stationary would be nice. Your thoughts?

[Dan Karachio]

You have no idea how noisy that 3 gun deal is. I have it, it is a killer. Loudest darn thing in the shop (if it's the Bostich). It is so loud, I'm betting it can do damage.

[Scott Hildenbrand]

I won't go oil-less due to the noise.. They really are that bad... In fact, I've got a tractor that threw a rod which sounds about as loud.

I'm happily still using my grandfathers compressor, built in the 50s.

[Bob Borzelleri]

After too many sessions of machine gun rattles and clanks from "oil less" pancake compressors, I switched to a Makita MAC2400. I didn't try the smaller MAC700 or the larger MAC5200 but I have a buddy who has the 700 and he likes it. It is adequate and quiet. The 5200 wasn't readily available in my area and it cost near $400 so I went with the 2400 at $299.

No regrets. In addition to running with oil, it has a 1720 rpm pump which really reduces the noise to an acceptable level.

Forgot to mention that the 2400 runs at 79 db while the 5200 is at 90 db.

[Jim Kirkpatrick]

Bob, Thanks for the Makita tip. I'll definitely look into that more. It looks like an improved version of my Emglo.
Dan and Scott, Yes it was the Bostich and believe me, I was leary. Particulary when the display model was on a shelf about chest high, and I could still lift it off with one hand....and I'm no strong man.

I had a contractor do some work on my house in the spring and he had this Dewalt (http://www.amazon.com/DEWALT-D55146-2-Gallon-200-PSI-Compressor/dp/B000HZJLV2/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1258547226&sr=8-4) compressor. I was amazed at how quiet it was given it's an oil-less. But looking at it last night at Lowes, it's got wheels for a reason: it's heavy. I can't see myself luggin it up and down stairs. Aside from the heft, does anyone have any experience with it?

[John Callahan]

http://www.thomasairpac.com/products/airpac/renegade_electric/T-200ST/images/T-200ST_125px.jpgimho some of the best portable compressors on the market are made by Thomas here in the US ................ and they're oiless. I've has the T-200ST for about 5 years. Good output- 4.6 cfm @ 100psi, reasonably quiet- 75dB (motor runs at 1700 rpm), starts fine when cold and runs no problem on a 15 amp circuit. Made in the US, they cost more. I'd buy it again. Rolair makes some great compressors .......... a lot of contractors use 'em; they tough to kill. Jenny (the folks that make steamcleaners) bought the Emglo plant after B&D mover Emglo production to Mexico- they have a model that looks to me like the old Airmate. Bang for the $ though, the Mak is tough to beat.

[Steven DeMars]

http://www.thomasairpac.com/products/airpac/renegade_electric/T-200ST/images/T-200ST_125px.jpgimho some of the best portable compressors on the market are made by Thomas here in the US ................ and they're oiless. I've has the T-200ST for about 5 years. Good output- 4.6 cfm @ 100psi, reasonably quiet- 75dB (motor runs at 1700 rpm), starts fine when cold and runs no problem on a 15 amp circuit. Made in the US, they cost more. I'd buy it again. Rolair makes some great compressors .......... a lot of contractors use 'em; they tough to kill. Jenny (the folks that make steamcleaners) bought the Emglo plant after B&D mover Emglo production to Mexico- they have a model that looks to me like the old Airmate. Bang for the $ though, the Mak is tough to beat.

I have a Rol-Air, great compressor . . . . but it is very LOUD ! ! !:mad:

[Greg Portland]

If you want a quality portable then look at Thomas or other option that is rated for continuous duty. I have completely abused mine for the past 2 years. Having said that, I'm probably going to add a stationary compressor (2 stage) in my shop for applications that require higher air flow.

Another solution for you could be the IR GarageMate line of compressors (oiled, continuous duty, semi-portable, can drive some spray guns, etc.). It depends on how 'portable' the compressor needs to be.

[Stan Mitchell]

I picked up an Ingersoll Rand DD2T2 last summer on an Amazon price drop. Very nice little compressor and it gets high marks in reviews. Seems very similar to the Makita in many respects.

133080

[Ray Newman]

First of all, how much do you ‘wanna’ spend?

Next how big 5, 20, 25 gallons?

And verical or horizontal?

I'd look around for a 20 - 25 gal. cast iron oil bath compressor. Unless your running air tools and ratchets, I don't think that you'll need a humungous compressor.

It might be worth while to look in the local Yellow Pages under air compressor repair/rebuild and give them a call or stop by and see what unit they would recommend.

I have a 15 + year old Dayton (Grainger) unit w/ a 25 gal. tank on two wheels. The only maintenance has been a yearly oil change and a new air filter. I added an aftermarket drain valve on a small extension to facilitate tank draining, which I do after each use.

An oil-less unit is very noisy and from what I have observed, oil-less don’t seem to hold up as long. Now maybe the newer units are better, but I like “iron“.

If you don’t have a Grainger account, find someone who does. Grainger has some interesting goods in its catalogue. Or if you have a re-sale/business license, open your own account.

For ‘zample': Grainger item # 4TW29 USA Made oil bath cast iron Compressor, Running Motor Power 2.0 HP, Tank Capacity 20 Gallons, Voltage @ 60 Hz 115/230 Volts, 15.0 Amps, Free Air Flow @ 125 PSI 5.0 CFM, Free Air Flow @ 90 PSI 5.7 CFM, $461.00. Grainger on-line catalogue also has some USA made Speedaire closeouts at very attractive prices....

[Mike Cruz]

I have had a Grizzly for over 10 years without issue. As a matter of fact, I have done NOTHING to maintain it. Not even drain it! I keep wanting to and then forgetting. I probably have a pint of water in there. Hey, a pint, that reminds me....

[Stephen Tashiro]

What's a resonable expectation for an air compressor when you use a high volume air tool like an air chisel or spray gun? Should you expect the motor to run most of the time? Or is that an indication that you need a model with a bigger tank?

[Mike Cruz]

I wouldn't get a portable for spraying. First of all, I think you need a compressor with a minimum air flow of what, 5 or 6 CFM @ 90 psi for spraying and air tools? I would certainly get a larger unit for spraying. On that note, my understanding is that even, say a 26 gallon compressor with 5.5 cfm, would be able to handle spraying, but would labor.

If your compressor labors, it just shortens its life. You CAN pull 10,000 lbs with a half ton truck, but if you are going to be pulling every day, you are better off with a 3/4 or 1 ton. Bottom line is how much stress are you putting on the compressor, and how much is it designed for.

[Justin Freund]

I have the Dewalt Emglo compressor in the link. It doesn't get used all THAT often and I've had it maybe 2 years but it now has a bad pressure switch already. It scared the crap out of me when I looked over and saw the needle wrapping 300psi. I haven't looked into replacing it yet but I'm not happy.

[Bill White]

I have a Craftsman oiled jobby that has been in the shop(s) since 1978. Has a Leeson motor that has had a starter cap. replaced. The job-site pancake Porter-Cable has been at work since 1999. It (the Porter) ain't quiet, but when I put it in the right place on the job......
Bill
Oh...I do drain it every day. :p

[Doug Carpenter]

I agree that the Thomas compressors sre really nice. That being said I never owned one. I know people that have them and speak well of them.

I have a Senco Oil splash. It is a really nice one. I had the single tank Dewalt one and it wasn't that great. It was extrea trouble in cold weather. It leaked alot when it was cold and had trouble starting.

Funny too because I thought emglo made Dewalt's compressors.

Anymore I would like to get the Thomas single tank. I don't know what maodel it is but it is small and you can carry it with one hand. A contractor friend of mine framed a basement for me with it and not only was it strong enough for the framing gun but it was nice and quiet. I would like one for those days when you are going to some trim or something. It was really easy to carry. I don't know about you guys but those things are getting harder to carry. I always hurt myself lifting them.

A guy that works for me has the Porter Cable pancake style and it isn't worth it weight in dirt. and neither are the three guns that came with it.

It oveheated on us when we where running one roof gun.

Just my opinions.

[Callan Campbell]

What's a resonable expectation for an air compressor when you use a high volume air tool like an air chisel or spray gun? Should you expect the motor to run most of the time? Or is that an indication that you need a model with a bigger tank?

Yes, if you're running the compressor too much to keep up with whatever tool/task you're doing, you might need a larger model. Most manufs. have decent worksheets on their websites to help figure out your usage/load, but way too many air tools are understated in TRUE air consumption. Lots of variables too, like sanders that use much more air than an impact tool since you're sanding for awhile and impacts or air hammers get used on and off.
Most people will say 5HP compressor as a minimum if you want to run larger air tools and/or a spray gun and not constantly have to watch your compressor cycle on to keep up. DO NOT buy an air sander unless you have a serious air compressor, use electric sanders and save big bucks in electric bills. Having said that, I once painted an old VW that I owned with nothing more than a borrowed portable 2HP compressor. I took my time,and ended up with a car all the same color. We won't go into the quality of the paint job...... One more thing, please remember that home owner compressors have a much shorter "run" time rating than an industrial unit. The people who built the unit are expecting a short run time, with a longer off time to allow the pump to cool down. Usually it's 60/40 to 70/30 for light duty compressors, and better made pumps are 80/20 up to Continuous Duty with synthetic oil being used to cool the compressor instead of dino oil. Hope this helps you out

[Don Morris]

I've had the DeWalt Emglo portable for about 5 yrs and an older Craftsman 2hp, 20 gal tank, 220V machine for many years which is more or less non-portable (goes from one end of the basement shop to the other end of the basement so as to be nearer the garage and cars). I've painted a car in my day with the Craftsman, but I wouldn't want to try that with the DeWalt. The DeWalt goes between my house and my sons to do trim work, molding, etc. and that sucker is LOUD and although I can carry it, when my son is around we help each other carry it as we know it's on the edge of being "Portable".

[Rick Fisher]

The whole Makita line of Compressors is very nice.. quiet and powerful. Great bang for the buck..

The DeWalt Emglo line up is a sad story.. lots of emglo parts that where once cast iron are now aluminum.. I would pass on DeWalt Emglo.. (Black and Decker .. sigh)

Jenny are good, Thomas and Rol-air are very good..

Bang for the buck, the Makita is hard to pass up..

[Craig McCormick]

The $99.00 Husky Scout is pretty quiet and oil-less. I have one of the original ones in my service truck. We have been using it for about four years now in our remodeling business to run nail guns and our drywall texture gun.http://www.homedepot.com/catalog/productImages/300/e0/e0c58316-ce02-4f63-9026-71cefb148135_300.jpg

[Rob Robinson VT]

The whole Makita line of Compressors is very nice.. quiet and powerful. Great bang for the buck..

Bang for the buck, the Makita is hard to pass up..
I second that, have had a Makita MAC2400 for nearly a year now and would buy one again in a heartbeat.

[Matt Meiser]

I have a $90 HF twin hot dog which has served its purpose nicely. But last night I was a Makita MAC700 which is just over $200. I seriously want one of those now! Very quiet compared to my HF.

[Jacob Mac]

I have a Bostitch, and it is the ludest thing in my shop. It is even louder than my Grizzly lunch box planer. And that is saying something. But, the three guns I got with it work pretty well.

As I grow in the hobby, less noise and dust are becoming much bigger considerations for me. I am not sure I would get the Bostitch again for that reason. At least, I wouldn't use it in the shop.

[Dave Gaul]

I've had a Porter Cable pancake style for over 6 or 7 years with no problems at all, and the finish nailer and brad nailer it came with have performed flawlessly as well! It does seem to be a little on the loud side, but I don't have much to compare to.

My dad has an even older and smaller PC pancake style that is still running strong to this day.. and he uses his on an almost daily basis.

[Sam E Miller]

I 3rd the Makita MAC2400

[Rob Robinson VT]

I 3rd the Makita MAC2400
And it's only $303.49 at Amazon right now:

http://www.amazon.com/Makita-MAC2400-Big-Bore-Compressor/dp/B0001Q2VPK/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1258752474&sr=8-1